subscribe: Posts | Comments

British Justice Secretary still refuses to apologise for rape comments

3 comments

Comment on and summary of story from The Telegraph, May 18, 2011

British Justice Secretary Ken Clarke has been desperately trying to salvage his career following allegations that he does not believe all crimes of rape to be equally serious.

The allegations followed a BBC “5 Live” radio interview yesterday in which Clarke attempted to defend government proposals on rape sentence reduction.

During the the interview Clarke implied that he did not think “date rape” or intercourse between 17 and 15 year olds were serious counts of rape.

He was later challenged in the same programme by Gabrielle Browne, a rape victim who broke down in tears as she denounced the 50 per cent discount proposal as “a disaster” (see WVoN story).

Calls for his dismissal followed and, in a desperate attempt to explain himself, Clarke toured the television studios to insist that he regards all rape as a serious crime.

However, asked if he was apologising by the BBC he responded with: “I haven’t apologised, as far as I’m aware.”

Despite this, yesterday evening Clarke’s office released an excerpt of a letter that he had written to Gabrielle Browne in which he said all rape was serious and he was “sorry if my comments gave you any other impression or upset you”.

And this is meant to let him keep his job?

Rape is becoming a crime of diminished responsibility.

It seems, in Ken Clarke’s world anyway, that if the victim and the perpetrator know each other, and the perpetrator abuses his relationship to take sexual advantage of a woman, that’s less of a crime than raping a woman on the street.

If someone is 17 years old and grooming a 15 year old into having sex with them, that’s not a really serious form of rape.

Ken Clarke and those like him are contributing to a society that is becoming increasingly desensitized to sexual crimes.

Maybe if he apologised it would have been different, but he hasn’t, not really.

He’s said sorry to one woman because she caught him out and exposed him for being the out-of-touch, chauvinistic judicial figure that he is. That isn’t apologising for being wrong, that’s apologising for being caught. The plans to reduce sentence lengths are still in place.

All rape is bad but some rape is less bad than others?

I think it’s time for Mr Clarke to leave his post.

  1. Kashan says:

    How out of touch can you be? He is just plain offensive, I can not believe his attitude towards rape but I guess its easy for a man to diminish rape as a serious crime, they don’t seem to realise the psychological devastation it causes.

  2. Simon King says:

    Actually I’ve been talking to a lot of young women about this issue recently. There are a large number of them whose views of the diminished responsibilities of rape tally with Ken Clarke’s. Now, there are a number of reasons that can be cited as being responsible for this: Inheriting the values of the white, male hegemony, losing any sense of self-worth in sexual objectification, being desensitised by a culture that is increasingly pornographic and violent. However, what it does mean is the chauvinistic perception of rape, the male gaze, is no longer limited to males.

    It has shifted and it has mutated, rather like a virus does when it jumps species. In this case it has jumped genders and has become something dangerous and out of control with its own rituals and instigators that can act independently of male stimulus. Men and women are now both contributing to this diminished view of rape and any attempt to challenge it that ignores the male gaze in its female form will fail. It will fail because the mutation no longer needs males to reinforce it.

    Now I don’t like Ken Clarke. I find it hard to like anyone who takes a diminished view of rape but there are plenty of other high profile women who support him too. Perhaps one of the reasons for male knee-jerk reactions to feminist responses is that frequently women like to limit their admonishment to males. As a male I find myself often being stereotyped as sex-obsessed, incapable of saying no, insensitive, cheating, and a walking rapist time bomb because it’s only ever a matter of time before a man does it. And that’s about as accurate as pointing to a woman on the street and saying she’s a dirty slut who can’t be raped because she’s always gagging for it. We are attaching these stereotypes to each other, forcing each other to take on polar opposite roles and it’s just making us hate each other.

    Isn’t it about time that we said that an increasing proportion of both genders are viewing rape as a diminished offence? All I see is a lot of misdirected aggression on both sides because a prominent minority is calling them into disrepute.

  3. jiff davis says:

    A letter has been sent to the British prime minister by Mr Paul Randle-Jolliffe regarding the case of Hollie Greig, who is a downs syndrome girl who was systematically raped whilst under the protection of the establishment charged with protecting her.

    Hollie’s mother Mrs Ann Greig would like to see some justice for member of the establishment, who through their positions were given access to this little girl and abused her as their own personal little sexual play toy. The reason Mrs Greig has never had the opportunity to have her day in court is because the accused paedophiles include lawyers, police and a local High Sheriff.

    Various request under the freedom of information act (FOA) have been ignored and several people including her mother and Mr Robert Green have been silenced using gag orders including the BBC’s Panorama documentary channel in an effort to keep the story out of the public domain and the establishments have even gone so far as to make legal threats against Google.

    This fight to bring justice has been raging for several years and despite millions of people now knowing about the case, it still seems that the British justice system is unable to live up to its name and has become a tool of the elite and Mr Cameron is hereby put on notice that ‘we the people’ demand this case should go to trial in open court where both sides may present their case.

    Put quite simply Mr David Cameron we tax payers are being treated with utter contempt by the elite and are getting a little sick and tired of the system we are forced to pay into when it is you’re duty to ensure due process is observed or expect no mercy when you and the establishment is overthrown by the people you pledged under oath to defend.

    MP Mr Kenny Macaskill, Mr Ian McFerran, Mrs Elish Angolini (Lord Advocate ), Frank Mulholland Are all aware of the case details and I am sure they won’t mind in assisting the prime minister in any preceding public enquiry into this disgusting clear breach of justice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *