subscribe: Posts | Comments

Can single mums turn boys into men?

6 comments

Comment and summary from Voice-online, May 30, 2011

A feature entitled ‘Can single mums turn boys into men?’  throws up some interesting points for debate.

It reports how the Office for National Statistics has found that 48 per cent of African-Caribbean households in Britain are headed by a single parent, and 36 per cent of African households are too.

The author asks if women can provide the discipline which young men may need?

While it broadly concludes that women can, its hypothesis is based in traditional values that young men need to become ‘men’, and that a disciplinarian is required to achieve this, and this is usually a male role model.

It quotes BabyFather author Patrick Augustus as saying: “Young boys mimic their father and it’s important to have their fathers around to create a balance. For a lot of men who haven’t grown up with their fathers, they take that bitterness to their graves.

“I’ve also seen a few cases where young boys without a father figure in their lives have become very effeminate.”

The article, while adding balance to the quote above, does not seem to address that a loving hug may help the confidence of a young man more than strict regime – whether this comes from a mother or a father.

  1. Jane Osmond says:

    Hmm, having brought up a son as a single parent I do agree that boys do need their fathers around – in the teenage years especially. However, I would argue that it is a ‘good’ father figure they need – having an unreliable/addicted/violent father figure around within a conventional marriage for example, does more damage than having a loving mother but no father.

  2. earwicga says:

    ‘A feature entitled ‘Can single mums turn boys into men?’ throws up some interesting points for debate.’

    What are they? There’s nothing I can see of any interest in this rubbish.

    • Jackie Gregory says:

      I was interested in the fact that the article seemed to be saying that boys needs dads for discipline in order to become men, and was asking if mothers can provide that.

      I

      • Jackie Gregory says:

        (Hi moderator sorry pressed button before finished please add this)

        I was wondering whether this was the correct question. I would ask the question should a father’s role be a disciplinarian, is that what boys need or lack if there is no father around, or do they need something else like love, affection, someone just taking an interest from a male as well as a female.

  3. Catherine says:

    It’s maddening that the ‘single mother’ is always questioned for her ability and her family structure doubted.

    The whole issue with ‘single mother’ households is men who have absconded their responsibilities OR been forced from contact with the family.

    In which case, it’s high time we saw articles questioning men – their responsibility, their obligation, their ability, their involvement with their SONS and daughters.

    Right now, the subtle message is ‘blame single mothers’ for every little social woe.

    But hey, they are the parent that stayed at least.

  4. Claire says:

    Kids do need boundaries. I’ve seen single mums who are very firm with their boys and single mums who are too soft or make the mistake of treating their kid like an equal.

    It just depends on the person raising the child. All down to individuals.

    Teenage male psychology is very different to teenage female psychology. I was a very quiet teenager, so if I were a single mother to a son who socialised with a gang …. I don’t know what I would do. Whereas a father who has been a difficult teenage boy would be able to cope better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *