subscribe: Posts | Comments

Castration is no response to rape

4 comments

By Asiya Islam
WVoN coeditor
The Guardian, May 14, 2011

An Indian court, while recently sentencing a man for repeatedly raping his minor stepdaughter, expressed concern over the growing incidence of rape in India and suggested that it could be curbed by alternative punishments, such as chemical or surgical castration.

In my opinion, by suggesting surgical or chemical castration as punishment for sex offenders, the court is reducing the crime of rape to a mere physical act of the insertion of penis, fingers or other objects into a woman’s vagina.

It implies that if a man’s testicles are removed surgically or his libido lowered through chemical administration he would not be able to, nor would have the desire to, rape a woman.

Furthermore, recommending castration as punishment inevitably leads to “scientification” of rape.  Blaming superfluous production of the male hormone for rape almost makes the crime excusable, for the rapists “can’t help themselves”.

The psychology and sociology of rape, however, go far beyond that simplistic assumption.

In the particular context of India, we do need to accept that incidences of rape and sex crime have been growing over the years, but they cannot be answered by castrating rapists.

Low conviction rates with long waiting times and victim-blaming remain the main reasons behind the failure to deter rapists/sex criminals. Not higher levels of male hormones. And that’s what needs to be changed.

Researching and writing this article also made me realise that while Iran is so often called ‘barbaric’ and ‘medieval’ for meting out ‘eye for an eye’ kind of punishments, when it comes to the developed world castrating rapists, nobody raises a word and thinks it justified.

Can I also thank WVoN for forewarning me of the misogyny that follows below the line on Cif? I experienced it for the first time today.

  1. Karen Whiteley says:

    If I’d have known before hand about your article, I’d have warned you, too. It takes a determined nature to stick it out on CiF – though I did give you a thumbs up under my top secret CiF identity (and you thanked me, too!). Great piece, well done.

  2. Jane Da Vall says:

    Those same men who were clamouring for castration today will tomorrow be horrified by the naming of an accused rapist. That was just today’s line of attack against a feminist article. Likewise, there will soon be outrage at the suggestion that testosterone may be causative in rape. It will mirror the disdain here for feminists ignoring the rapists who simply can’t help themselves. It is one more day in a long running campaign against women on CiF which the Guardian sees fit to indulge.

  3. Victoria says:

    What I am concerned about more than about scientification is that castration does not prevent sexual abuse. Penises are but one amongst a myriad of things that are used to penetrate women. And not all sexual abuse is penetration after all. So the logic seems pretty faulty to me.

  4. Heather Kennedy says:

    Yes, research has shown that chemical; or physical castration doesn’t work; if someone is hell bent on rape and have been castrated, they will use an implement instead, which can actually be more damaging to health of the vicitm. This takes us to the truth that feminists and other campaigners have been arguing for years, that rape isn’t about sexual desire but about violence and power.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *