subscribe: Posts | Comments

Cheerleading may yet become a recognized sport

13 comments

Summary of story from Jezebel, May 23, 2011

Two groups are campaigning for the US’s National Collegiate Athletic Association to recognize competitive cheerleading as a sport.

USA Cheer and the National Collegiate Athletics & Tumbling Association are each presenting a proposal for how the new sport “acrobatics and tumbling” will use a scoring system similar to that of gymnastics, with points based on degree of difficulty.

A recent New York Times article found that schools routinely lie about their numbers of female athletes. Women still make up 53 percent of the student body at Division I schools, but only 46 percent of athletes.

This program is aimed at encouraging schools to add new sports for women, and could lead to cheerleading becoming a full championship sport.

For years the debate has raged over whether cheerleading is a sexist activity or a rigorous sport consisting of difficult gymnastic maneuvers and stunts. Either way, it is one of the most dangerous activities for young women, accounting for 65 percent of all female ‘catatrophic injuries’ in high school and college.

Nancy Hogshead-Makar, Senior Director of Advocacy at the Women’s Sports Foundation, says: “As long as it’s actually operating as a sport, we welcome it into the women’s sports tent.”

Like gymnastics or figure skating, “this is another aesthetic sport that if done right could provide lots more girls with legitimate sports experiences.”

  1. Jane Osmond says:

    Hmm – I can go with this as an exacting sport if they do not wear revealing clothing

  2. Jackie says:

    I am afraid I could not go along with it as a sport even if they do not wear revealing clothing, as it seems to me to be all about the adoring female supporting the male athlete. The female cheerleaders are peripheral to the actual game, which belongs to the men. It seems to reflect the wider societal gender order.

  3. Karen Whiteley says:

    I agree with Jackie; cheerleading is just too loaded with implications of women ‘supporting’ men, who are therefore the ones actually doing the stuff that’s considered ‘important’.
    Which is a real shame because there’s no doubt that it is, of itself, a rigorous sport – if you watch these cheerleading competions some of the stuff they do is amazing and requires extremely high levels of athleticism. Which makes it all the more of a shame that it’s still considered to be the side-show to the main event.

  4. Jane Osmond says:

    Yes you are both right – no matter if they were dressed head to toe in sacks, they are still peripheral to the main event so no I cannot go with it as a sport.

  5. Starr says:

    Allowing cheerleading to be a NCAA approved sport would be a disaster for both men’s and women’s sports. I’m not just talking about side line cheering and poms poms but competitive cheer as well.
    If colleges offer up to 30 scholarships for competitive cheer then this will be to the detriment of other sports. 30 places would include, for example a soccer, hockey and volleyball team and still leave places for other sports. Most of these scholarships would be for women (if not all) and would take the place of existing sports.
    Face facts: Colleges have already lied. Adding cheerleading is not going to prevent any of these colleges from lying in the future. A better rule would be to limit the number of football scholarships thus leaving more spaces for “minority” men’s sports e.g. soccer, wrestling and for all women’s sports. NCAA authorities should conduct more regular and stringent examinations of colleges to ensure compliance with Title 9. Colleges which cheat should be fined.
    Cheerleading is the easy and cheap way out of Title 9 compliance. Just get 30 girls together and let them dance and do a bit of tumbling. Colleges have tried and failed to eliminate more expensive sports e.g. Volleyball and substitute cheerleading which is the cheapest look at Quinnipiac – “Cheerleading is not a sport”.
    http://abcnews.go.com/US/judge-cheerleading-sport-quinnipiac-university-squad-title-ix/story?id=11219913
    Professional sports in America is very sexist, cheerleading is soft porn and getting more graphic each year.
    I’m tired of seeing women in skimpy outfits at sporting events with the b*lls*it excuse that it adds “glamour”. They don’t use the chippendales to bring more women into watch the games do they?
    Cheerleading/Dancing girls is backward not glamorous. It’s ridiculous that in the 21st century sports organisers lazily resort to selling sex i.e. sexism just to make a fast buck when there are so many other ways to market a sport.
    I don’t feel the least bit sorry for any women who are fired. They know it exploitative and sexist and that it offends women. As far as I’m concerned they get what they deserve. Pity their employers aren’t fired too.
    It’s bull to say the only way to get girls to exercise is by cheerleading, there are so many sports out there and thanks to shows on TV dance classes are inundated with new pupils.
    Finally if cheerleading was based on race or any other criteria it wouldn’t be allowed. So racism is bad but sexism is good?

  6. I think that when most people hear the word “cheerleading,” they think of girls bouncing around at male sporting events. That is not what this article is addressing. This article is talking about competitive cheerleading. There are hundreds of highly respected club teams worldwide (many of them co-ed) that compete in huge tournaments and cups (and, what they do is more difficult and more dangerous than American Football). Male members of cheer squads have stated in interviews that the training they go through for their cheer squad is far more rigorous than what they went through for football. The image shown with this article is misleading. It is not of a competitive cheer squad. It is an image of cheerleaders at a football game. The two are completely separate. I have been an athlete all my life, and I believe that the incredible athletes that dedicate themselves to competitive cheer deserve recognition for what they do. Particularly in the US, there are thousands of cheerleaders who never set foot on a football field. They begin training and entering competitive club teams at a young age, just like any soccer player or gymnast.
    Also, as for the “revealing clothing” argument… I mean no disrespect, but I have been running cross country since I was seven years old, and what we wear is more “revealing” than any cheer uniform I’ve ever seen.

  7. Jane Osmond says:

    Dear SK
    Thank you for your comment: if I could just address this comment ‘what we wear [when running cross country…is more revealing than any cheer uniform I’ve ever seen’ – I would argue that this is also suspect – why does female sport involve women wearing very little clothing? I get the point that due to friction etc, a lot of clothing cannot be worn, but this does not mean that the clothing has to be sexually suggestive, surely?

  8. Karen Whiteley says:

    I think there’s the difference: cross-country running requires few clothes because of chafing etc; cheerleading requires few clothes because the ‘ladies’ are supposed to turn the menz on. Very different.

    I do agree with you though, SK – as I’ve already posted above, competitive cheerleading is athletically amazing and I totally agree participants deserve recognition for what they do, but can this happen when, as has happened here, cheerleading for the vast majority of people is nothing to do with athleticism and everything to do with sexual subordination (oh, yeah, go you guys! Cos you’re, doing the important stuff!)?

  9. Hello, Jane
    Yes, you are correct, we wear very little clothing in cross country to minimize wind resistance (no one wants added friction when you’ve been running uphill for ten miles). However, male cross country runners wear clothing just as tiny as us female runners (and they wear even less during training). But, I agree with you, clothing should not need to be sexually suggestive in female sports, which is unfortunately what many people automatically think when they see cheer uniforms.

    Hello, Karen
    I agree that there is a difference. But, as an athlete, small clothing doesn’t just minimize friction, it also allows for a maximum range of movement. (Which would be very important to competitive cheerleaders, as it is to gymnasts and synchronized swimmers for example). I agree that it is highly unfortunate that so many men look at athletes and only see sex. But, I don’t think that female athletes should let this male perspective determine whether or not they compete. And, I don’t think that we should let that determine which sports we recognize.

  10. SK
    Any compeitive cheerlading I’ve seen the men are in loose shirts and pants and the girls are in very short skirts and often showing mid-riffs. Why don’t they dress more like the men?

    I say this about all sports and don’t even get me started on beach volleyball. Any female who plays that and complains about not being taken seriously just start dressing like the men.

  11. Hello, everyone
    Some of the comments seem to be missing. 🙁 The last post I can see is my own that I posted in response to Jane and Karen. I know that both Starr and I posted at least one comment each after this… Is there a problem with my laptop? Or does everyone only see a total of 9 comments as well?

    • Hi, there, SK, not sure what has happened as I usually publish the comments. We’ve been having a few problems in general today, having gone over to a new server although I’m not sure why that would have affected the comments. Can you remember when you posted them?

      • Hello, AlisonClarke
        I’m very sorry, but I don’t remember the times. I only know that both Starr and I posted additional comments yesterday. But, I wish you the best of luck with your new server. I shall, of course, continue to visit your wonderful site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *