Do girls just want to be housewives?
Summary of article from The First Post, May 10, 2011
Academic Stephanie Coontz reflects on the fact that Kate Middleton’s decision to be a stay-at-home-wife has been well received by social conservatives, who claim this is the aspiration of most women.
It’s a view supported by Catherine Hakim of the London School of Economics, who claims that woman wanting to pursue careers and have financial independence is “a feminist myth”.
A Sunday Times poll is used to back this assertion, showing that 69% of women prefer to stay at home and look after their children. A higher proportion of women are also marrying men more educated than themselves than in 1949.
Yet looking beyond the headline figures a different story is told.
The Sunday Times poll also showed only 19% of women actually preferred their partner to be better-educated, with the vast majority preferring intellectual equality.
Sociologists suggest that women marrying better educated men may reflect another trend, such as a preference for men with more egalitarian attitudes towards housework and childcare.
There is also evidence that the popularity of staying at home shows variety across countries, depending on the social policies in place to make life easier for working mums.
US research has shown, for example, that for most career women who left their jobs, it was not their first choice to do so, but necessary because of inflexibility in working practices.
With more women in low paid, laborious jobs than men, it’s also easy to understand the superficial attraction of a life where you don’t have to worry about going out to work.
But as the author says “be careful what you wish for, especially if your mate is not the future King of England.”
















Mary Wollstonecraft wrote over 200 years ago about the terrible effects of lack of education, marriage and economic dependence on men for women. She saw first hand the violence endemic in marriage and the impossibility of escape for women who had no money of their own and no hope of earning any. This is still the case for women who do not have financial independence and the self confidence and freedom to choose how to live that goes with it.
Why does society continue to promote the model of the economically dependent housewife to young women? What is so scary about self confident, independent women? Are they an affront to male pride and male power?
These women are still choosing men who earn more, or have the potential to earn more.
Women can support themselves on $10/hour, yet they still generally marry men who earn more.
What a sexist article. It makes me ill that people still wish for the daughters to aspire to be dependent on men,
You can take the woman out of the 50’s, but you cannot take the 50’s out of the woman.
Women are college educated and in many cases are outearning men in similar positions. Still, these women generally want to marry up. Female doctor marrying a male nurse? No way, she will hold out for a male of at least equal finances. Male doctor marrying a female nurse? Sure, it happens all the time.
@Stan Women might be able to support themselves on $10/hour when they are single, but it’s not so easy if they wish to have a family. As the article states, women generally want to marry men with equal intelligence. As the women become more educated, they are therefore going to look for relationships with men who are as intelligent as they are. My subjective view too is that young women are often more interested in slightly older men (who may or may not have better prospects) just because their peers are not so mature. That’s why I married a guy 5 years older than me because he was more mature and egalitarian in his attitudes than the other men of my age and of equal intelligence. As to the difference between countries, there’s a much bigger percentage of working women with young children in, say, Belgium because the social conditions are better geared towards very low priced but well run child care facilities close to one’s place of work, well organised activities to occupy kids out of term time and it has to be said a history of grandparents happily pitching in to look after kids during the long summer holidays as well. The story is much broader than you paint it…
I have been out with men older than me and younger than me and have consciously chosen men that have good manual skills as well as a brain in their head. As a child of the 70s, I was brought up to earn my own way financially and never really considered a man’s wage in light of their suitability as a partner. But the moment you have a child, the whole picture changes, totally. Its not that you can’t take the 50s out of the woman Stan, its the fact that men’s attitudes and therefore our current childcare arrangements are still grounded in the 50s. Give women good, free childcare and a supportive partner willing to pull their half of the child and housework and it is a whole different picture amongst my friends, but you need both otherwise poor pay, inflexible bosses and a spouse’s emotional blackmail can be very effective dissauders in the fight to get out of the house.