French foreign minister wants to be the “world’s banker”
Summary of story from the Observer May 29, 2011
Christine Lagarde, the French finance minister, has been the topic of much interest and speculation following the announcement of her candidacy for International Monetary Fund (IMF) leader (see WVoN story).
Her bid for the job, following the arrest of former head, Dominique Strauss-Kahn on sexual assault charges (see WVoN story), has not been universally welcomed.
There are complaints from countries that the job should not automatically go to a European, as it has since the fund was created in 1945.
Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa argue that the shifting balance of global economic power makes this tradition an anachronism.
However, everyone who knows the minister – and even some who don’t – agree that she is extremely well prepared for the job and, with her firm but fair approach to handling other people’s money, would be very good at holding the planet’s purse strings.
Her candidacy has attracted the support of heavyweight politicians such as US secretary of state Hilary Clinton (see WVoN story), German Chancellor Angela Merkel, former UK chancellor Alistair Darling and current chancellor George Osbourne, making her the current favourite for the leadership position.
Even the French president, Nicholas Sarkozy, who is known to consider her a political lightweight, has described her as a woman of “great qualities”, even if she did have, as he said at last week’s G8 summit in Deauville, a “predictable personality”.
Not forgetting Kenneth S Rogoff, a former IMF chief economist, now a professor at Harvard University, who considers her “enormously impressive”, a “rock star” of the world of finance.
Fans of Lagarde’s no-nonsense approach to the economic crisis cite her run-in with Barclays Bank chief Bob Diamond at the World Economic Forum in January as an example of her quick wit and sharp tongue.
When he thanked finance ministers for creating a better economic environment, Lagarde retorted: “The best way for the banking sector to say thank you would be to actually have good financing of the economy, sensible compensation systems in place and reinforcement of their capital.”
Cue stunned silence from Diamond and applause in the auditorium.
She has publicly said that men, left to themselves, tend to make a mess of things, and that if Lehman Brothers had been Lehman Sisters it might not have imploded, sparking a global financial crisis.
Lagarde also believes bankers need rules and regulations, and fiscal discipline has to be combined with fair social and welfare benefits, but she can be hard and human in the same breath.
On one US chat show, she described how she fired a couple of bankers for doing a “crappy job”, then finished the interview by whipping out a beret and sticking it on her head.
French politics can be something of a closed shop, constructed as it is on layers of machismo, propped up by a network of (mostly male) graduates from the Ecole nationale d’administration (ENA), the elite school for civil servants, which she twice failed to get into.
She probably would not be where she is today if she had, she says, but it has made her an outsider on two counts: not a graduate of ENA, not a man.
Although a fierce proponent of women’s equality, she does not believe quotas are a long-term solution. Personally, she says, she would always choose a woman over a man of equal ability for a job.
She says women in high places are essential to avoid “gender-dominated environments where men have a tendency to show how hairy chested they are, compared to the man who’s sitting next to them”.
“There should never be too much testosterone in one room,” she said recently.
WVoN comment: As nice as it is to think that diluted testosterone in the boardroom will nurture a healthier capitalism, I don’t subscribe to the idea that a woman in charge of the IMF will lead to a brighter future with a more stable economy.
The issue here is not the characteristics and qualities of the “world’s banker”, but the principles that underly the world’s bank.
Current economic policies embrace rampant capitalistic intent where the priority is not to get the most worth from a situation, but to make the most profit out of every situation.
This perpetuates a competitive, divisive and unequal world that is better at breeding corruption, discontent and misery than anything else.
A woman in charge of the IMF, will have no transformative impact on power relationships.
It cannot be denied that Lagarde’s succession to IMF leadership would be a personal triumph for her, but let’s not confuse it as a victory for woman and mankind.
For full WVoN coverage of Christine Lagarde, please click here.











