subscribe: Posts | Comments

India’s “ruling women”?

0 comments

Summary of story from the BBC, May 17, 2011

Do women really rule India?

It’s true that the chief of the ruling Congress party, the President, the Speaker and the Opposition Leader are all women.

Then there’s Mayawati (a so-called untouchable), Sheila Dikshit and Mamata Banerjee (pictured) – rulers of Uttar Pradesh, Delhi and Bengal respectively – who rule over a third of India.

But Indian politics remain deeply chauvinist. For all the glib talk of gender equality, the Communist Party of India (Marxist) has no female leader of any standing.

India also doesn’t have a single Muslim female leader, and the matriarchal states of the north-east are all ruled by rather unremarkable men.

The remarkable achievement of women’s political empowerment in this context, when many mothers still die in childbirth and more girls drop out of school than boys is, therefore, no quirk.

So how much of a real change will Ms Banerjee and her sorority bring for the people of India?

It has not been a very inspiring record till now – Ms Mayawati seems to have belied a lot of expectations in the way she runs Uttar Pradesh, and Ms Dikshit’s record has been marred by shoddy infrastructure work for last year’s Commonwealth Games.

There is still no evidence that women politicians are less corrupt than their male counterparts. “To suggest that women in power will be less corrupt is fatuous, and contrary to all prevalent evidence,” says journalist-writer MJ Akbar.

Historian Ramachandra Guha says the rise of women in powerful political roles does not mark a “new age” of gender equality. The reasons for their rise, he says, may be personal (their courage and drive) or historical (the impact of a generations of reformers) or political (universal adult franchise).

Whatever the reason is and whatever its consequences, he says, the phenomenon is noteworthy.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *