Iran to blind man who threw acid in woman’s face
Summary of story in the Washington Post, May 14, 2011
Iranian judicial authorities plan to blind a man this Saturday, after he was convicted of throwing a bucket of sulfuric acid in the face of a young woman who had refused to marry him.
International human rights organizations and the British government have asked Ameneh Bahrami, 34, to pardon Majid Movahedi, who has been in jail since his 2004 crime.
But Bahrami, who was disfigured and blinded as a result of the attack, says she does not intend to do so. Instead, she hopes the punishment will be a warning to any man ever contemplating such an act.
In 2008, an Iranian court ordered that five drops of the same chemical be placed in each of the attacker’s eyes, acceding to the victim’s demand that he be punished according to a principle in Islamic jurisprudence that allows a victim to seek retribution for a crime.
Only the victim can prevent the execution of the sentence by pardoning the convicted.
“I have been receiving numerous phone calls from Iranian human rights organizations based abroad,” Bahrami said in a phone interview Friday.
“They are pressuring me to pardon him. But I won’t do that.”
Bahrami wrote a book on her experience entitled “Eye for an Eye,” which was published in Germany.
In the years since the attack, she has travelled between Iran and Spain, where doctors have tried unsuccessfully to restore her vision.
Blind and alone in Barcelona, she spent periods of time living on the streets, until she received assistance from the Spanish government.
She has been the driving force behind the implementation of the punishment, pressing Ayatollah Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi, the former head of Iran’s judiciary, to carry it out. He had proposed that the attacker’s family pay her compensation instead.
“He explained that such a sentence [the blinding] would cause lots of bad publicity for Iran. But I refused,” she said in an interview with The Washington Post in 2008.
“I don’t want any woman to have to go through what I experienced,” she said.
WVON comment: I feel uncomfortable about this. On the one hand I completely understand Bahrami’s need for justice and also the need to send out a message that throwing acid in people’s faces is not on. But, I am not sure about the punishment – it feels inhumane. Anyone else conflicted?
















I can understand her anger, & I think her reaction is partly down to the status of women in Iran. This is the only power she has, so she wants to show it in revenge. Frankly, I don’t think it’s a justice system if it lets victims revenge themselves; they should have just handed him over to her family if victims really have that power. I don’t know if it’ll really make her happy, but it’s a depressing way to show him that he was wrong.
Thank you for your comment Tanya – yes, it is depressing. And yes, a good point – if revenge is allowable, then they could have handed him over.
I cannot blame the woman who has been blinded, for wanting her revenge. What happened to her is unspeakable on so many levels but she should not have the responsbility for passing judgement on her attacker. Perhaps she will get some immediate relief from violent revenge but more than likely she will feel let down by the process and feel much worse in the long run – does she need guilt added to her burden? The individual should be dealt with by an impartial and fair process which sends a very strong message to men who feel it acceptable to attack women who turn down their advances. Personally I would lock him up and throw away the key but then again I’m not his judge – I don’t have that burden and neither should she.
If in the future even just one man decides not to throw acid in a woman’s face for fear of similar punishment, it will be completely worth it.
There is that.
I just cannot agree with this “eye for an eye” point of view. I understand that Ameneh Bahrami must be feeling very angry, and I agree that she probably does feel justified with requesting retribution due to the way women are treated in Iran. However I don’t know that putting acid in her attackers eyes will make her feel any better, or make sure if never happens again. It’s only going to cause more suffering and it cannot turn the clock back.
this man should have been blinded yrs ago when he did it… i strongly believe in eye for an eye…how dare he take this young womans sight because she rejected him…taking his sight from him is the only way he will understand what he has done to her…he should be glad their not disfiguring her face as well like he did to hers…hurry up and drop that acid in his eyes!!!!!
If the ‘eye for an eye’ approach really worked, then states operating the death penalty would have low crime rates. Unfortunately, human nature and emotion isn’t so easily controlled. As I said above, I think Ameneh Bahrami is exercising the only power she has in this situation, as she lives in a society controlled by men, which is why this man thought he had the right to do this in the first place. It doesn’t make her response right, which is why most human societies have a justice system which doesn’t let victims take out their revenge. It’s a negative response (contrast the awareness-raising work of Katie Piper on disfigurement, who also had acid thrown in her face), because there’s very little Ameneh Bahrami can do which is positive. Very sad.