Irish government facing UN Committee Against Torture over Magdalene Laundries
May 24 saw the UN Committee Against Torture (UNCAT) repeat its requests for an independent investigation into Ireland’s Magdalene Laundries and for redress for the women who suffered under the scheme.
‘Magdalene Asylums’ were set up by the ‘rescue movement’ in Britain and Ireland in the 19th century to ‘rehabilitate women who had worked as prostitutes’.
In Ireland, the institutions were named after St Mary Magdalene, who according to Catholic tradition, repented her sins and became one of Jesus’ closest followers.
The Magdalene movement in Ireland was quickly appropriated by the Catholic Church, and the homes, which were initially intended to be merely short-term refuges, increasingly turned into long-term institutions, and ‘penitents’ were required to work, mainly in the laundries.
Women who were socially classed as ‘fallen’ were also admitted for behaviour such as promiscuity, having ’social dysfunctions’ and having children out of wedlock.
During its 150 years it is estimated that 30,000 women were admitted to these places, often forced there against their will, by family members or priests.
Children and adolescent girls were confined in the ‘laundries’ as late as 1970.
There are five distinct groups within the ‘survivor’ community: those now speaking out and
demanding justice; those living in silence due to the ongoing shame/stigma; those dependent on and living in the “care” of the religious congregations; the adopted children/families of former ‘Magdalene women’ – and victims who have died – many of whom are buried in incorrectly marked mass graves.
Speaking at the UN meeting, Seán Aylward, Secretary General, Department of Justice and Equality, and Head of the Irish Delegation, responded to questions about the Irish government’s failure to investigate the abuse by repeating his assertion that it all happened a considerable time ago in private institutions.
He argued that the Department had received no complaints of criminal offences from laundry survivors, and said that the majority of women entered the laundries voluntarily, and if they were minors, with the consent of parents or guardians.
He added that only one institution in Dublin was used as a remand centre, when the period of detention lasted only a matter of days in most cases. He also claimed that this institution was subject to inspection and that there is no evidence of mistreatment.
He concluded by informing the Committee that the government is considering how to deal with the issue, and that he cannot anticipate how it will decide to respond.
In her response, Madame Myrna Kleopas, the Committee’s Deputy Rapporteur, reiterated that it was the responsibility of the state to investigate abuses in the Magdalene Laundries and to find ways to ensure redress for survivors.
The acting chairperson of the Committee, Felice Gaer, refuted Mr Aylward’s assertion that these abuses happened a long time ago and therefore could not be put right.
The Committee, she said, had addressed similar issues in Japan, Algeria, Cyprus and Canada, and was concerned with the prevention of such abuse in the future, in accordance with Article 10 of the Convention – on education about the prohibition of torture.
Responding to Mr Aylward’s assertion that the majority of women entered the laundries “voluntarily,” Ms Gaer asked: “What is voluntary?”
For more information on the ongoing fight for justice for those exploited by the Magdalene Laundries click here.
For more information about the Magdalene Laundries click here.

















Dictionary definition of ‘voluntary’:
performed, undertaken, or brought about by free choice, willingly, or without being asked.
Synonyms of ‘voluntarily’: free, unforced, natural, unconstrained.
Aylward, by the use of that single word ‘voluntarily’, has denied the whole repressive nature of those Institutions.