Playboy comes to London, but does London care?
When I was a kid the word Playboy was sacred. Everyone in the playground knew what Playboy meant.
Playboy was naked women, symptoms not just any women but the sexiest naked women imaginable. Blonde hair and big boobs and American.
Playboy meant bunnies and a mansion in California and some cool guy in a dressing gown who lived everybody else’s sexual fantasies.
Actors and rock stars and millionaires dated the women in Playboy.
Anna Nicole Smith, view Carmen Electra, Pamela Anderson, I knew who they were. Every kid did. They were famous.
When I finally got hold of the internet and worked out how to use Google images, those were the first names that I typed in.
And then I’d seen them naked. Five minutes went past and I’d seen a lot more women naked. Playboy became tame and boring within half an hour and I’d never even had to buy a magazine.
At school, in ICT, we’d all sit around trying to find ways of getting around the security firewalls so we could get access to porn in the classroom.
And Anna and Carman and Pamela? They got left behind along with the bunnies and the mansion and that guy in the dressing gown.
It wasn’t cool, it wasn’t new, it wasn’t hardcore and let’s face it, that cool guy was kind of old. Wasn’t he just a better dressed version of the old perverts drooling over Jakki Degg at the bus stop?
It was 2001 when I was allowed to have access to the internet. Playboy’s shares have been on an erratic, yet steady, drop since 1999.
Earlier this year Hugh Hefner bought all of them and privatised the company for a fraction of what it was once worth. No longer able to satisfy the world with porn, Heff intends for Playboy to become a marketing brand, but how successful is it really?
W.H. Smith doesn’t stock its stationary anymore, the audience image that it carries is not so much that of gentlemen but rich, spoilt frat boys, and isn’t the fantasy that it creates just one dirty old man’s wet dream?
A new Playboy Club is opening in Mayfair on June 4. The “Eff off Heff” protest group can be found on Facebook here along with details of how you can get involved.
But do we really need to? Isn’t this just the desperate attempt of one little boy who never grew up to find some more friends to play with?
Hugh Hefner may be the father of modern pornography, but his relationship with it now is tenuous at best.
The grooming of children into a pornographic culture is more advanced and depraved than it was when I was a kid, and something should be done about it.
But you may as well shout at the old man at the bus stop. Porn’s new facilitators are elsewhere, and they don’t want anything to do with sad, pathetic old Heff.

















Certainly, some of London does care. They’re probably the same section of the population which got WHSmith to remove the merchandise from its shelves. To say that Heffner and his bunnies are irrelevant now that, oh, lots of other stuff is so much worse, isn’t it? misses the point. Heffner is now an ‘establishment’ figure of the porn industry, the acceptable face of women’s objectivity. By saying he’s now ‘tame’ and a bit passe merely opens the door the accepting more overt porngraphy as ‘normal’.
Heffner puts women in a rabbit costume and serves them up to men for pure, sexist titillation, and he’s been so successful at it, that people now think he’s almost quaint. I care about that shift in perceptions quite a lot.
Actually I don’t think that Heffner is an ‘establishment’ figure of the pornography industry anymore. I don’t think that the porn industry has any establishment figures anymore, neither does it have a clear brand identity, neither does it have a regimented and controlled production process. Its referentials have disappeared and it’s become far more concentrated on erotic effect than any figure worship.
I don’t find Hugh Hefner quaint, but I do find him rather redundant along with his bunnies and the rest of his brand. That doesn’t just go for Playboy either I should add. Penthouse, Hustler, Larry Flint, Jenna Jameson, they’re all redundancies left over by a pre-internet production line method that doesn’t exist anymore. This development is worrying and it is significant, but focusing attention on these redundancies won’t tackle what the porn industry has become, it will just distract attention away from it.
Pornographic internet sites that emulate the Youtube model have allowed anyone with internet access to get hold of as much porn as they can physically watch. Yes, there are still “stars” within the industry, but the ability to consume far more material online than you ever could while being forced to wait for a magazine’s next instalment, has diminished their power. They just can’t satisfy consumer demand.
As a result of this what we’re beginning to see are more and more people turning to amateur porn. Amateur porn is becoming increasingly popular. Viewers are ceasing to relate to the traditional Playboy pornographic fantasy. They realise that it’s fake, they want something newer, harder, something more involving. They don’t want the bunny and the mansion, they want access to the sex tapes of their peers. They want access to sex tapes that don’t have branding, that don’t have people they recognise, that are free of all the semiotics of late twentieth century porn.
They want access to forms of pornography that are far more dispersed and invulnerable to attack than what Hugh Heffner is trying to provide them with. Porn’s consumers do not want Hugh Heffner anymore. Hugh Heffner does not know what they want anymore.
And where is this leading to? It’s leading to people who are getting increasingly bored by the saturation of internet video porn. One of the great things about online games is that you can use them to fantasize. They become one large communal fantasy. When sex takes place in an online environment, it takes place free of legal, societal and physical constraints. It allows participants to develop and construct new forms of extreme and temporarily satisfying pornography that do not even require the actors of video-based porn.
A lot of people find that this is a healthy, mature way of exploring their sexuality in a safe environment. However, for those people who already have an unstable grip on reality, when sex takes place online, when they participate in their own pornographic fantasies online, they become increasingly incapable of making the distinction between a fantasy world and a real world.
What’s happening is that people are coming away from these new pornographic environments and are coming back to reality and having difficulty readjusting to social norms. Now in the years to come I think this is going to exaggerate people’s inability to empathise with the real world. New, extreme pornographic forms that are appearing on the internet, and I think that we need to be trying to understand and take control of them now, while they’re still in their infancy.
And that’s why I think that whatever Playboy may have once been, now it is tame and normal. It’s unfortunate, it really is, but if people want to counter the damage that it’s done to society they need to focus what the porn industry has become, not what it was. High Heffner is just a desperate, pathetic Frankenstein caught between chasing his monster and trying to recreate it, incapable of either.
The shift in perception that Playboy’s normalisation is important, but so is the shift that is continuing to take place between the fantastic and the real. It’s high time focus shifted to the nebulous entity that pornography has become.
What I would say to your argument about Playboy being redundant is that it formed the gateway to all that has followed and also provides an acceptable mask to hide all the depravity that men are currently inflicting on women and children in the name of making films that they can sell to other men, who can then go on to recreate these fantasies in real life by pressuring young girls and women into have more and more damaging and painful sex (anal, gagging and violent) in order to make fantasy reality. It’s a cycle of abuse and women tackle it anyway they can and wherever they can. You can afford to take an intellectually distanced and academic view of the irrelevance of this approach if you like – but some of us have been at the sharp end of this treatment and have four year old daughters growing up in this scumhole of a country and are seriously worried about how she is going to defend herself at the age of five from a bunch of 8 year old boys who have been dabbling with internet porn in the same way that Jamie Bulger’s killers dabbled with video nasties. And whenever I or others flag this up to the State, the media, the police or any other male dominated institution, I am called a crabby lesbian feminist and so the cycle continues with nearly every man colluding with it by turning a blind eye or dissing the efforts of a few lone voices pointing out that most porn isn’t very nice to women and children.
Playboy has been a gateway, one of many gateways but I think we need to look beyond it. One of the reasons why it works so well as an effective mask is because anti-porn movements attribute it far more prominance in the shaping of modern attitudes than it really has. All I want is for people to start taking a much broader look at the porn industry because I think there are far more sinister elements that are being overlooked and are contributing to the dangers that you’re citing.
It gets much worse than video on the internet.
I’m not against protesting against Playboy, but I am against ineffectual protest. Yes I take a distanced view of the industry, but I try and take a distanced view of anything that I really care about. That way I can get a better picture of what’s really going on. I’m sorry if it seems dispassionate, but in writing I tend to exercise more control over my words than I would in heated speech. By the sounds of it though, we’re on the same page.
Yes, I misunderstood your original article – but I still stand by the fact through discussing Playboy’s return, it has opened up a conversation about on line porn and what is currently being played out around the world in the distorted world between fantasy and reality that gamesters inhabit. And hopefully, through groups like Objects Eff Off Heff photocalls, there will be a few media readers that see that not all human rights activists are grim faced witches and that there are people out there willing to stand up for girls and women’s rights to live free from sexual harm.
The problem with your argument Simon is that you have forgotten to replace ‘people’ with men in your article. Yours is a particular viewpoint based on being a male consumer of porn and so your take on this – that Hefner and Playboy bunnies are passe is quite offensive to women who think that Hefner and the Playboy bunnies are equally as vile as some of the present day porn because they both perform the same function – i.e. as female objects provided as wanking material for men.
Although the word “people” doesn’t actually appear within the article, you are right in saying that my viewpoint based on being a male consumer of porn. Where “people” was used, in the response, it was used consciously in taking a wider view of how both men and women interact with porn in an online age. I didn’t meant to cause any offence with what I’ve said, but I don’t think the Playboy brand is as “vile” as many of its contemporary forms. Playboy is well known, it’s easy to attack, it’s concentrated enough to rally around, but to porn consumers it hardly lives up to its legend. Using Playboy as a rallying cry against the modern porn industry is fair enough, but the attentions of those that it calls to arms needs to then extent beyond it.
Practically speaking this is Hugh Hefner who, after years of slumping shares, a declining readership and failed attempts to sell his brand of “softcore” videos to a consumer market, has privatised his company. In an attempt to regain some of the empire that he once had he’s decided to invest heavily in the Playboy brand, believing it still has some credibility amongst porn consumers. As a male, I’m saying it has not.
Unlike attempts to market bunny ears, playboy tattoos, or stationary (and I quite understand that they’re still a part of the Playboy machinery and will undoubtedly see a surge of re-investment if it can be afforded), this is the establishment of a strip club in Mayfair. It is meant to be perceived as elite, exclusive, gentleman’s porn. Hugh Hefner is attempting to regain his credibility by concentrating his efforts on a very specific, narrow demographic (unlike Hooters who are aiming to break into the UK’s university towns).
He wants to serve up a specific brand of women as an industrial, flattened, object or image. As he himself said in a 1967 interview:
“The rabbit, the bunny, in America has a sexual meaning, and I chose it because it’s a fresh animal, shy, vivacious, jumping – sexy. First it smells you, then it escapes, then it comes back, and you feel like caressing it, playing with it. A girl resembles a bunny. Joyful, joking. Consider the kind of girl that we made popular: the Playmate of the Month. She is never sophisticated, a girl you cannot really have. She is a young, healthy, simple girl – the girl next door…we are not interested in the mysterious, difficult woman, the femme fatale, who wears elegant underwear, with lace, and she is sad, and somehow mentally filthy. The Playboy girl has no lace, no underwear, she is naked, well-washed with soap and water, and she is happy.”
And that is, I assume, the “female objects provided as wanking material for men”, that you were describing.
Here’s the problem though, the bunny was what wanking material was in 1967. Since then the pornographic material available to men has become much more extreme and one of the worrying things about this material is that it functions rather like an oubliette. The more extreme pleasures men discover as they progress along it, the harder it is to find pleasure in the less extreme material they enjoyed previously. Furthermore, once they begin to realise that they’ve found more pleasure in more extreme forms of sexual effects, the more inevitable it is that they will continue to explore.
How is this affecting women? Women, who have been groomed for thousands of years into forms that men have found sexually pleasing are having to adapt. For girls with low self-confidence one of the easiest ways to find self-worth is through being found sexually pleasing. In an online world, the ability to use someone else’s profile picture to define yourself, and to describe yourself as a completely different person, makes it easier than ever to find gratification in being treated as an object there. Furthermore, the need to keep up with male perceptions of what is sexy, is leading to
their objectification becoming increasingly extreme.
In online games we have the ability to choose and edit how we look. I can be taller, I can be more muscular, I can look like the perfect alpha-male. I can take on the physique that I assume is sexually appealing to women, be the alpha-male gentleman that Playboy desperately wants to appeal to. Women, in exchange, can and do take on the form of the Playboy girl. At this point in time the two of them begin to take on the roles of actors in pornographic fantasies.
And the problem with fantasy is that it’s hard to impose and regulate limits. Rape, Necrophilia, BDSM to the point of death, that’s what’s taking place in people’s minds away from Mayfair and its gentleman’s club. The porn industry has become a seuxal fantasy shared in the minds of two people. Far from containing the flattened, visual, objectified woman on a centre-fold, the woman in question begins to move and excite a physical response. Within the controlled, user-imposed constraints of the fantasy, she is free. Porn has become far more involved than the flattened, objectified, wanking material that you’re talking about, ever was.
That’s dangerous. Now that it’s starting to become normal for people to fantasize about these extreme acts, how long is it until it develops to the next stage?
Hugh Hefner has helped to develop this industry. He’s groomed men and women into these roles and a variety of successors have then served to further degrade both sexes. But Hugh Heffner wasn’t the first, just the most recognisable in living memory. I don’t think that he and his Playboy brand are as “vile” as their modern day equivalents, and I don’t think that the sexual object is the same thing now as it was in 1967. I don’t mean to cause offence but I’m far more worried about the degradation of human identity that’s taking place on the internet now, than in trying to attack someone for what they once were.
Hugh Heffner likes the world to think that he’s one of the big movers and shakers of modern sexual values, but he’s not. He’s a pig, a pathetic pig, getting off on the fact that people think he’s still important enough to arrange a protest about.
And yes, I’m using people there, because porn cannot be reduced to a male-female dichotomy. Few things can.
That’s dangerous. Now that it’s starting to become normal for people to fantasize about these extreme acts, how long is it until it develops to the next stage?
I think it’s already happening Simon – there was a 45% rise in rapes in London last year alone. I spent 25 years in PR, tracking how media campaigns changed people’s perceptions and behaviour around subjects in the media – and whilst it is an inexact science – monkey see, monkey do, especially when rewarded by pleasure incentives along the way such as orgasm – is a proven facet of human behaviour. Why anyone should think the media of porn is any different is beyond me – but the fact that people seem to be constantly looking around the elephant in the room to concentrate on ‘freedom of expression’ seems to be completely myopic and totally ignores all that we have learnt about our ability to indulge in cruelty on a massive scale if we make the recipients of that cruelty less than human – objects – as happened in Nazi Germany, Rwanda, South Africa, Serbia etc.
Hello Simon, welcome to WVON. I do have a couple of points about your article on porn – I think you are missing the point that it doesn’t matter what the porn is – whether it is playboy or hardcore = porn is porn is porn is porn. Women who have been harmed by the pornification of our culture do not make any distinctions between the type of porn because it is all equally degrading to women. I think this is the point that is coming through in the comments loud and clear. A much more useful discussion is how we get a general acknowledgement that all porn is harmful and not get bogged down in ‘types’.
Vicky, yes two of the great things that can be accomplished through protests like this are the opening of wider debates on the effects of porn, and removing the stigmas attached to human rights activists. I just want to make sure that we don’t get caught in a situation where those broader goals are ignored for the sake of achieving tangible yet limited short-term successes. Especially when those successes come at the cost of ignoring new, sinister developments.
As for the increase in reported rapes, I’ve seen some similar figures those those you’ve cited. However, I’ve found it difficult to track down any sources that can show detailed developments over a period of years. I might have to invest some time in charting the changes against a chronology of the porn industry to try and understand and show how it has changed the way in which people act. There’s definitely a lot more room for studies to be done in this area, and I think that without the studies it’s going to be difficulty to break free of the “crabby lesbian feminist” stereotype that gets applied.
Another one of the reasons why more detailed studies need to take place is that porn is not porn, at least not from a consumer perspective. I understand Jane, how you can feel that all porn is equally degrading and want a general acknowledgement that all porn is harmful. However, one of the reasons why anti-porn campaigners have such difficulty in getting through to consumers. is that they take a hard-line approach that leaves little room for understanding a complex, ritual-orientated culture.
“A general acknowledgement that all porn is harmful” requires an admission of guilt, and that will always put opponents on the defence and shut down discussion. Time needs to be taken to see how men and women are being inducted into this mechanism, and how it’s affecting them. And then, and only then, once we’re able to talk to people honestly and without putting them on the defence, can we start to repair some of the damage that has been done.
If not, these arguments that have failed for years will keep coming up against brick walls that do not want to listen.
Hello Simon – I am sure we are all very grateful for your better informed take on the problem of pornography and look forward to you surprising us with your findings.