subscribe: Posts | Comments

‘Shocking defeat’ predicted for women’s representation in Scotland

0 comments

Summary of story from The Herald, May 5, 2011

It is election day in Scotland and some commentators are predicting that tomorrow night could see the lowest level of women MSPs (Members of the Scottish Parliament) since devolution began in 2002.

Anne Johnstone of The Herald predicts ‘a shocking defeat for around half of Scotland’s population: women’.

According to her figures, the proportion of women in parliament could fall to almost as low as Westminster, where only 22% of the seats went to women last year.

Only 29% of the seats are being contested by women, and there is a similar picture in Wales.

The high point for representation of women in the Scottish Parliament was in 2003, when 51 out of 129 seats went to women (39.5%). This then fell back to 43 (33%) in 2007.

The reason for the predicted reductions this year is partly due to a relaxing of measures taken by parties, most notably Labour, to ensure gender balance in selection.

All five Labour women constituency MSPs who are stepping down have been replaced by male candidates.

As Johnstone says, gender balance matters to ensure fairness in a democracy, with women more likely to get involved, and alter the political agenda, if they are represented. The author concludes that strong equality guarantees are necessary to end the continued male dominance of politics.

WVoN comment: It is clear that action needs to be taken to ensure more balanced representation in all the UK parliaments and assemblies. The new institutions started promisingly, but the ‘new politics’ has so far failed to emerge.

But on a positive note, some political analysts have been more upbeat in their predictions of the number of women who will be elected today. Malcolm Harvey at Better Nation, for example, predicted 47 seats (36%) would go to women,  an increase from 2007. It may be by luck rather than design, but here’s hoping this is closer to the truth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *