subscribe: Posts | Comments

The inevitable pitfalls and pratfalls of teaching abstinence

2 comments

Comment on and summary of story from the Guardian, May 28, 2011

When the delightful UK journalist Zoe Williams starts an opinion piece with “The sight of Nadine Dorries MP on the crest of a wave is never a pleasant one, for a feminist, but there she blows.” I know that, as usual, she and I are on the same page.

Nadine Dorries, for those not in the know, is a prominent UK anti-abortion campaigner, but recently, she also came out as somebody who advocated – and proposed a bill to the effect – that girls should receive compulsory education on the subject of sexual abstinence (see WVoN story).

Only girls, though; boys apparently can carry on saying yes to sex to their hearts’ content, though it raises the question of who they’ll be having sex with when all the girls are saying no.

A roundabout endorsement of homosexuality amongst boys probably wasn’t Dorries’ intention, but it’s a thought that makes me laugh nonetheless.

As Williams points out, in her concern with abstinence, Dorries is not alone.

We have good, concrete evidence of what happens when you try to teach abstinence to teenagers: it has been tried, trialled, tested and analysed on a huge cohort: America.

Williams points out that not everybody involved in pioneering abstinence programmes was a religious fundamentalist; some were just trying to do their best by their young citizens in a world that doesn’t always provide the facilities and information young people need to navigate sex safely.

But religious fundamentalists or not, the real issue about teaching abstinence is this: it doesn’t work.

As Williams says:

“If you look for the flagship abstinence programmes now – Not Me, Not Now in Rochester, Facing Reality in Louisiana, even True Love Waits a national, Christian abstinence charity that never relied upon federal funding – it’s like an internet graveyard. They’ve all closed.”

The reason is not that Obama came in and redirected funding to a more liberal curriculum, rather, two things happened.

The first was that federal funding started to come with more and more stringent requirements – that nothing else would be taught, that no access to clinics would be available, at one point they were trying to roll out the message for everybody under 29 (yes, really).

This put many people off.

Secondly, and more importantly, the US Department of Health and Human Services finally released, in April 2007, a study on the effectiveness of four abstinence-only programmes.

The study found that abstinence-only students became sexually active at the same average age as the control group, and only a quarter of either group used protection.

Three different research projects, released at a similar time, showed that abstinence programmes delayed the start of sexual activity by a small amount, but made young people less likely to use protection when they did become sexually active as well as less likely to seek help for sexually transmitted infections (STIs).

It was effectively endangering the youth population by misinformation, since abstinence was never taught in conjunction with safe sex. In fact, a message of abstinence doesn’t coexist very convincingly with a message about safe sex

Often educators would never mention contraception, except in the context of the (often made-up) risks it carried.

One teenager told Williams:

“I think kids are really misled about sex, by TV and songs and stuff. They give this image that it’s clean, and it isn’t. They throw a white sheet over it and it’s clean, but underneath the sheet it’s all nasty and dirty. They don’t understand that.

“A lot of people don’t know how you can get yourself into trouble with having sex. Just like all the sexually transmitted diseases that are going round. People don’t know, when they’re having sex with a person, whether they have AIDS. It’s just so unsafe that people shouldn’t be doing it.”

Williams sees this attitude as the reason for the link between teenagers taught abstinence and their decreased use of condoms and reluctance to seek treatment for STIs.

Williams says that “you cannot teach chastity without attaching a stigma to sex, and once you do that, you chase adolescent sexual activity underground. Which is ridiculous, because they’re going to have sex anyway.

“Even if only 10% of them had sex (in your dreams, Nadine Dorries!), we still have a public health duty to those kids.”

For one, there are huge implications for teenagers who explore supposedly “risk-free” anal and oral sex as an alternative to “unsafe” vaginal sex.

As Williams points out, teaching abstinence had many other problems besides.

The first is that it is incredibly difficult to teach sex-only-within-marriage, unless it’s from a religious perspective.

Some programmes decided to leave marriage out of it, but they ended up saying words to the effect of, “don’t have sex, until you want to; but don’t want to, until you really, really want to”. It was confusing.

Even when they made no mention of Christianity, these courses were still unable to avoid concentrating on the nuclear family as the ideal, castigating any alternative.

This alienated single parents, who were outraged at their children being explicitly taught to avoid, at any cost, ending up like their own families.

Another issue is that there was significant upset in America that the abstinence message seemed to take as its starting point that heterosexuality was the only acceptable outcome. An idea disastrously supported by an upswing of homophobic bullying in schools.

However even-handed abstinence is “taught”, it’s so often the case that the kinds of people who think teenagers should stay pure, tend to be the same as those who think homosexuality is aberrant.

Williams concludes that we, “could argue that we don’t have to do it like that: that we can do it without attaching gender stereotypes, without suffusing the conversation with shame, without attacking single parents and homosexuals, without pedalling untruths about contraception, without any of these didactic, misleading manoeuvres that run so counter to the aims of education.

“Good luck with that. But even if you manage it, it still won’t work. That’s the funny bit.”

  1. Jane Osmond says:

    Good piece. In the end it comes down to sexual health issues for me – young people will have sex anyway, so it would be good if they practised safe sex; also a good sexual education programme would explore the psychological issues that arise from having sex as a young person. Armed with both sets of information, some people may decide to wait, but if they don’t they will at least be a better position to make informed choices.

  2. Yeah abstinence-only sex education works in the same way telling teenagers that they are not allowed to drink alcohol until the age of eighteen does…

    We absolutely need education to keep our population healthy. To me that does not suggest a policy of telling young people simply not to do something. I’m appalled at the idea that areas of the US don’t teach about STI or protection from them, I wouldn’t like to see the UK follow suit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *