Most primary care trusts ignoring IVF guidelines
Summary of story from the Independent, there sale June 7, diagnosis 2011
UK women unable to conceive naturally are being denied IVF on the National Health Service (NHS) because they are too young, too old, too fat, smoke or live in Wales – in flagrant breaches of guidelines from the National Institute for Clinical Excellence (Nice).
One in six UK couples are affected by infertility. The World Health Organisation recognises infertility as a physical illness that requires treatment; however, it can also cause significant emotional and psychological harm to patients.
Nice’s guidelines state that couples should be offered three free cycles of IVF where the woman is aged 23 to 39. However, 70 per cent of primary care trusts (PCTs) ignore the guidance, with most restricting the number of free cycles to one or two.
Despite repeated government reminders, the guidelines have never been fully implemented across the NHS. The latest reminder was sent to Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) by the NHS deputy chief executive, David Florey, in January.
The All Party Parliamentary Group on Infertility sent Freedom of Information requests to all 177 PCTs in England and Wales in March and received 171 replies.
Gareth Johnson, Tory MP for Dartford and chairman of the group, said the variation in the criteria showed the Nice guidelines had been “taken out of context and used to place arbitrary restrictions on the provision of IVF”.
IVF has always suffered from the perception that, similar to cosmetic treatments, it is a lifestyle choice. NHS trusts searching for savings have seen it as an easy cut, but this has devastating impacts.
Infertility is borne in secret. Couples often do not tell their friends and families they are having difficulty conceiving so are unlikely to make a fuss if the service is cut. Yet the distress it causes is deep and real.
The Health minister, Anne Milton, said: “Many PCTs have made good progress towards implementing the Nice recommendations on the provision of IVF treatment.
“I am aware, however, that a small number of PCTs with historical funding problems have temporarily suspended provision of IVF services.
“ I have already expressed my concerns about this approach and would encourage all PCTs to have regard to the current Nice guidance.”
WVoN comment: These failures on the part of the government to regulate and direct divisions of the NHS are typical of a healthcare service in desperate need of reform.
PCTs are due to be abolished on 31 March, 2013. We can only hope that their successors are better able to provide treatment for this devastating condition.
















I am wondering what the situation is like for lesbian would-be mothers. I have heard how sometimes they are refused treatment because they may not be infertile, despite them “having tried with their partner for two years”, which seems to be the main diagnostic criterion.