subscribe: Posts | Comments

Batgirl returns…sort of

0 comments

Summary of and comment on story from Mail and Guardian, 14 June 2011

Barbara Gordon, the original Batgirl character, is to return in a new DC Comics series. Controversially, the once-paralysed Gordon will now be given the power to walk.

The reimagining of  Gordon is part of a broader strategy by DC Comics aimed at reviving public interest in its vast back catalogue of characters.

DC hopes to make them more relevant to today by keeping the characters, but rebooting the storylines back to square one so that they can be updated for a modern audience.

Other characters being reimagined include Superman and Batman, but it is the less widely-known Gordon who is provoking the most debate.

Gordon was left paraplegic after being the victim of a revenge attack by the Joker in 1988.

Many fans saw the decision to restrict one of the few female superheroes to a wheelchair as misogynistic. However, after being reincarnated as the character Oracle in 1989, Gordon became popular for her ability to solve crimes in cyberspace using her intellect.

Now, fans are expressing their disappointment at the removal of one of the things that made Oracle such an interesting character.

One fan, Lance, questioned the message that the new Oracle would send in a comment on a comics blog: ‘Unless Oracle is still present, it says that people with disabilities aren’t cool enough.’

The writer of the new series, Gail Simone, said that the controversy surrounding the newly-walking Batgirl would be balanced out by the value of her reappearance.

“She’s been removed from the action and danger for a long time. With this relaunch, she is still very much Barbara but she can reclaim part of her history and legacy with modern stories.”

WVoN comment: While I couldn’t be happier that DC is to revive one of the few female superheroes in this most male-dominated of worlds, it doesn’t mean I’m so grateful for being thrown a tiny feminist morsel that I’ll ignore any other discrimination that goes along with it.

Gail Simone seems to suggest that we should just be happy to see a woman character, but why should we have to choose between a disabled character and a female character? Can DC only bear one weird, transgressive challenge at once? Or is it that disability is somehow ‘unfeminine’, in a universe that still only accepts the most ultra-feminine body shapes?

This decision gives an unflattering sketch of DC Comics, and they need to get back to the drawing board.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *