subscribe: Posts | Comments

Feminist juror in New York police officers’ rape trial speaks out

2 comments

Summary of story from Woman’s eNews, June 1, 2011

Melinda Hernandez, a member of the jury that last week acquitted two New York police officers, has spoken out about the verdict.

Distressed by a process that she felt left her no choice but to vote not guilty, she says justice was not served (see WVoN story).

Hernandez told Women’s eNews in a telephone interview that ”as a feminist it really challenged my values to vote not guilty”.

In particular, she was concerned about the way forensic evidence – in a case concerning police as perpetrators – went through the New York Police Department lab instead of the New York Medical Examiners lab or an independent lab.

“I think they should have hired an independent person to collect the evidence,” Hernandez says. “There’s just common sense behind that.”

Although acquitted of the rape charge, the two officers, Kenneth Moreno, 43, and Franklin Mata, 29, were convicted last week of official misconduct and fired from the force the same day.

They will be sentenced by the State Supreme Court on June 28 and each face up to two years behind bars.

Had they been found guilty of rape, the pair could have been in jail for up to 25 years.

The verdict set off a storm of controversy in New York City, with a large demonstration led by members of the City Council’s Women’s Caucus, the New York chapter of the National Organization for Women, Feministing and Permanent Wave.

  1. vicki wharton says:

    This whole case stinks from start to end – if they had conducted a race trial like this there would have been uproar. The police collecting evidence around another police officer, the discrediting of a taped confession as a lie, the non questioning of why the policeman lied about his whereabouts on the night in question to his work, the video evidence of him visiting the woman three times in one night – this is all so flagrant a breach of justice it defies description.

  2. Vicki, I totally agree. It just gives the impression the whole investigation, trial and outcome was always going to favour the roles of the ‘policemen’ rather than treat them as possible rapists/actual rapists.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *