subscribe: Posts | Comments

For most women, free choice remains as unattainable as an investment handbag

16 comments

Jane Osmond
WVoN Co-editor

Charlotte Raven, writing in the Independent today, explores the impact of a recent book – How to Be a Woman by Caitlin Moran – which advocates all sorts of choices for women, as long as they are made for pleasure and not for profit.

In a thoughtful piece, Raven points out that although Moran’s contemporary belief that we are all free to “make our fate” communicates powerfully to the reader, the reality is that she cannot see the ‘the feminist wood for the trees’.

In this case the trees are the ‘propaganda of personal choice’ which represent a barrier obscuring the real inequalities that women experience every day.

Raven puts this down to the fact that Moran hasn’t considered the bigger picture – that what defines our choices and our identities are defined by capitalism and an exploration into feminism without this context misses the bigger picture completely.

Raven, I think, has hit upon the routine absence in discussions of feminism of the economic determinism within which we live and discussion without this context can only ever be about the choices that capitalism allows us to have, which are largely determined by the men in charge.

This may go some way to explaining why women are discriminated against in every area of their lives, and this is epitomised in the media where they are routinely sexualised and churned out as ‘product’ for mass entertainment.

That being so, we need to include in any discussions about feminism the economic system that we live within – one that is currently penalising the poor (read mostly women) to the extent where we now need FOODBANKS in the UK in our so called civilized society.

According to the Trussel Trust, 13 million people now live below the poverty line in the UK and last year their foodbank network fed over 60,000 people.

Therefore, any discussion of feminism divorced from economics can only ever be about having enough money to buy choices and identities that are offered up by a male-dominated capitalist system.

As Raven points out: ‘For most women, free choice remains as unattainable as an investment handbag.’

Comments welcome.

  1. The way the reviewer frames it, sounds like Moran’s book is more a How-To on being comfortable as a woman and not stressing too much rather than a call to arms. Definitely need to read it now, if only to see how accurate Raven’s assessment is!

    From the article: “Even the choice of how we write as women seems to have been narrowed down until only confessionalism is acceptable, reproducing as it does the very mode of expression of the culture it seeks to critique. Self-revelation has become the only form of address acceptable for a mainstream feminist writer. Is this really our only option?

    There are no feverish accounts of pre-teen masturbation in The Female Eunuch. In those days it was OK to make an argument that wasn’t filtered through the prism of personal experience. Today’s feminist writers have to flash their muffs and celebrity mates to get noticed.”

    I think that is very true. Not entirely convinced that ‘confessionalism’ was the intention but I’m sure we’ve all been in discussions where someone arguing from another POV has demanded proof. It is easy to fall into the habit of saying ‘but I *know*, I’ve *lived* it!’ rather than deal with theory all the time. Perhaps it’s time to head back the other way and deal in hypotheticals a bit more? (Yes, I know that’s a hypothesis too, sorry. 😉 I will get to work on testing it!)

    Why is the world always so concerned with women’s bodies? I shan’t rant about it, but look at the damage it causes for everyone.

  2. Jane Da Vall says:

    It’s true most women are not free to make choices in life, most men aren’t either. Capitalism may be a male-dominated system but it dictates the choices of men and women alike. Are women disproportionately represented at the bottom because we have a capitalist economy or because we have a sexist society or both? (Of course it is both, just for a change.)

    Women have responsibility for children and need more from the State. To that extent, capitalism works against them, but has any alternative system produced a society offering real equality? Not at all, and socialist organisations have historically discriminated against women with enthusiasm. Some do still, quietly. The loudest voices of feminist opposition today come from the left, jealous for the attention and resources that identity politics divert from the class struggle.

    Capitalism impacts differently on men and women, in some ways, and the consequences of societal discrimination are economic, in part. There are other forces at work, however, that an economic view of the position of women can lose sight of and which have nothing to do with capitalism.

    • Jane Osmond says:

      Hi Halla and Jane, thank you for your comments: my argument is still developing and it is good to have your thoughts.

      For me at bottom it is about who has the power to determine the economic structure – and to take Jane’s point that other political structures also discriminate against women – this again is because it is men that are in power in EVERY political structure, all over the world and they get to determine the economic structures.

      I know this is a circular argument and I try not to fixate on economic determinism, but I cannot seem to get away from this because the economic structure does matter. Witness the current economic situation in the UK – the coalition decisions (made by all men, all millionaires) affect women disproportionately whilst at the same time are ensuring that their wealth and the current capitalist system remains intact and making a profit. This disproportionate affect has a direct impact on women’s choices and identities – for example the identity of a working mother is only possible if you can afford to pay for childcare.

      So to sum up, for me it is about women living within a political and economic structure that determines who we can be, and also who we cannot be, therefore any feminist discussion that does not include these facts is not recognising that predetermined identities and choices have already been made for us: instead the discussion tends to focus on how awful it is that women have to have perfect bodies, or as Halla points out a focus on ‘Why is the world always so concerned with women’s bodies?’. Without acknowledging the context of the political and economic context within which women have to have the perfect body, then there is very little chance of change, because we will be aiming at the wrong target, i.e. the media makers instead of the politicians.

      • Hello Jane Osmond! 🙂

        In the absence of job or career opportunities and in the face of a tabloid bombardment of flesh, flesh and more flesh, I think women are being tacitly encouraged to commodify their own bodies as a way to ‘get rich quick’. I can’t remember the last time I saw a tabloid report congratulating hard work or study which led to achievement (but then I do avoid reading tabloids so if they have done this please set me right).

        The last decade in capitalism wasn’t even about investing for later returns, it was full of property programmes on the TV that emphasised how easy it was to make money and how quick in the midst of the property boom. There’s a tendency for everything to be immediate, and in that sort of framework there’s no room for children who need cared for or for people making ‘deviant’ economic decisions because they want a family and a home life, it’s more about someone who has become famous because of a TV show or who has gained a lot of money quickly by selling some aspect of themself. It’s really easy to feel trapped within these confines and to be swept into the pursuit of capitalism.

        It’s something the diet industry does too – if only we were good enough, better than we are, we’d be happy and successful. So women ‘have’ to look a certain way to be happy and successful, and if that means spending lots of money on clothes and creams and wearing heels that cause pain, so be it. Then we find out that we will be criticised for our efforts anyway…

        Sorry, thinking out loud again. 🙂

        We are seeing choices narrow – look at the recording and publishing industries, for example. The people who are concerned with making money there are narrowing the range of options we are given by promoting one particular brand or style over another. Less profitable styles aren’t given the same exposure. If we try and get all our shopping at one of the large supermarkets (forever stocking new lines but with a narrow range of choice within them) our view is further restricted to what they carry. I think this is happening to people in the developed West too. Women are to look one way to be taken seriously, men are to look one way to be taken seriously. Although the men at least still have the option to be seriously talented. (Women are expected to look glamorous *in addition* to being talented, although if a woman is ‘merely’ beautiful she will be lambasted for trading on her looks). I’m not remotely qualified to talk about how these expectations are put onto people who aren’t from the developed West but I don’t imagine they are exempt.

        And there I am, concentrating on looks again. 😐 How do we influence the economic structure? Even when women are in government it appears to make no difference. Cuts must be made, women will bear the brunt. The Tories are fond of the idea that women will be housewives though, aren’t they? I’d hate to think that we must be as wealthy as current policymakers to be heard but it looks like no one gets a say in the current economy unless they’ve bought in for a couple of million at least.

      • Jane Da Vall says:

        I think Charlotte’s criticism of Caitlin’s ‘live the dream’ message is well made, the availability of choice is economically driven and I am surprised that she would take such a superficial approach. I think she is thinking of more personal choices about how women see and value themselves, their looks, relationships, sex. Financial power gives men control of the fashion and entertainment industries and the media, but women make the choice to buy into it, they don’t have to. Those decisions are rarely economic at heart, as far as women are concerned at least.

        This government could give no better demonstration of the economic determinants of most women’s lives and how a male stranglehold of political power hits women directly and immediately in the pocket. In some ways I think it is a good thing, or will be. Women can actually see how that collective powerlessness manifests in their child benefit, their pay and opportunities, their own safety and that of their friends. Women will be powerless politically and economically until we form a collective voice and start harnessing the voting power that is available to us. Caitlin, I think, is making a valuable point about something else, which is a little disappointing, but then I haven’t read it yet.

        • One of the justifications Moran made for the book is that she wanted to create a safe space. I’m choosing to look at that space as a diving bell – after everyone is onboard we can descend into the ‘more serious’ levels. I welcome any book that invites women to reconnect with feminism and hope that they choose to delve deeper. Perhaps Moran will write a weightier tome as a follow-up?

          I started a bit of a discussion amongst some of my friends on FB about feminism and campaigning, one tells me she is concentrating on UKUncut at the moment. The more I read the more I think this is perhaps the best course to take at this time. Although movements like SlutWalk are valuable and the issues of violence and women are important ones, I think most of the weight should be thrown behind campaigns such as UKUncut because from economic deprivation come a host of other issues. Also it is a very practical way for feminists to (re)engage with mainstream campaigning after a period where I feel we’ve been slightly sidelined. As you say, we need a collective voice as we clearly don’t have the money as a group to force our agenda toward the ruling class. I’m not convinced that voting along will achieve change as all the choices are equally discouraging and in some ways it still abdicates power – perhaps it is time for alternative ways of organising and taking care of one another. It irks me that the Tories may be right when they say the State is too big but I don’t think I share their reasoning on why.

          • Jane Da Vall says:

            I think UKUncut are probably the strongest pressure group on the government right now but they are hopelessly outgunned by the City. Voting is the the only thing we have. We may decide to fnd another way to live but the City will keep hoovering up the wealth, the only check is the electorate’s control of government. This coalition government will not hold firm for much longer and then it will have to deal, and with the voters fairly soon.

            At the moment the banks own all political sides, but we are favoured by our geography. Being small and densely populated, the UK can generate popular political concensus quite easily, unlike America, which I believe will have an almighty struggle to regain the democracy that its utterly corrupt politicians have sold off.

    • Hi Jane, thinking out loud here so please excuse the rambling.

      I think the mix shakes down a bit more than women more at the bottom and men more at the top, of course we have more groups that are oppressed, some in multiple ways. I’m not about to make a chart of which group has it worst, obviously. 🙂 Only mentioning the complexity in play.

      I don’t know that women need more from the State as such – could it be that the dismantling of older ways of life (little mobility from place of birth, living in extended family units) has left a gap in the raising of children with the State attempting to stand in for relatives or friends who may previously have watched the children? (Not that I’m advocating that it takes a village to raise a child, although that’s what it sounds like…) So OK, yes actually women need more from the State but this is a manufactured need and the ‘liberation’ from domestic roles has not helped us as it might have done. Assuming we accept that we achieved that liberation… well, we got halfway there.

      Although I accept the struggle people in developed countries have navigating the systems we live in and the stresses it places on us, I am more concerned with the people capitalism grinds up to oil its gears. Slightly dramatic turn of phrase I suppose but only slightly. :-/ How can feminism help women in the slums of Nairobi, for example, who are having relationships with gangsters and will have a couple of children by their early teens? I find capitalism and the unbridled pursuit of profit to be an evil ideology that is of little use to people and I wonder how we can move away from it.

      • Apologies – the hi was to Jane Da Vall, going to read Jane Osmond’s comment now. 😀

        • Jane Da Vall says:

          Thanks, Halla! When I said that women need the State more than men, in general, I mean partly for child care, yes, also maternity services and financial support, on occasion. More fundamentally, though, they have a deeper interest in the formation of community and communal resources. Schools and hospitals are collective enterprises, requiring physical communities and shared values, principally the belief that children benefit the whole community. They are a mutual benefit justifying mutual obligation. This works against the liberal individualist spirit of capitalism.

          Capitalism chews up and spits out women in the Nairobi slums who have children in their early teens, yes. I actually spend quite a bit of time in and around Nairobi. Here are a couple of ways in which feminism is helping women:

          a) helping them not to have children in their early teens. Feminism fights the traditional views that devalue the education of girls. There is a direct relationship between increasing girls education and delaying first childbirth. That has a double impact on women’s economic position, teaching them skills that make them more employable and reducing the cost of children and childcare.

          b) promoting female reproductive rights – women are contracting HIV/AIDS at a faster rate than men. Traditionally, women have had little control of their fertility or contraception. Until recently, that impacted primarily on their economic position, but in the last 20 years it has been catastrophic. Feminism, promoting education and female political involvement, has been instrumental in women beginning to take control of their bodies and their lives.

          Does feminism cure all ills? No, but it directly improves the daily lives of women in developing countries in countless ways.

          There is not a straight line dividing men and women at any social level, no indeed, and I know that men’s choices in life are constrained too but overall, make no mistake, women are disadvantaged economically, politically and socially by the fact of being women. No society has wholly overcome that yet and all the while that men control 90%, 95%, 98% of the positions of power in every area of life in every direction one looks, it will not be overcome.

          • Wow, how serendipitous – I mentioned Nairobi because my local radio station sent people there this Easter and it had stuck in my mind. The presenters were all very affected by what they saw, even though they sent them for a weekend in total.

            If women have opportunities to be something other than a wife and/or mother then it follows that they will not bow to the inevitable and start having children earlier.

            How’s this for a stab at a working definition: Capitalism tells us that numbers count, it doesn’t particularly care about individuals only numbers. Doesn’t matter if half your workforce have to leave due to illness or whatever, as long as there are always more numbers clamouring for their jobs. Feminism contends that individuals should have rights and that they are valuable. Feminism only finds itself in conflict with men at those points where men have the power and control of society and its policies, because it seeks to address the lack of concern in the system that grinds people up to make money.

      • Jane Da Vall says:

        Halla, Increasing opportunities for women to work,study and socialise outside the home have had consequences, that is true. When they were at home women did not need child care. People in prison save on travel costs, but are they happy? I am being flippant, but I do not value any side benefit which accrues from being denied, by accident of birth, the freedom and opportunity to live ones life to the fullest.

        • Oh absolutely! I think we got halfway there though – we got the opportunity to have careers (rather than simply go out to work, as there have always been women who have had to work and who scoff at the rather middle-class feminist preoccupation with being *allowed* to work…) but didn’t manage to win the childcare situation yet.

  3. Reply to Jane Da Vall here as the subthread is too long again: 🙂
    “Jane Da Vall says:
    June 26, 2011 at 17:59
    I think UKUncut are probably the strongest pressure group on the government right now but they are hopelessly outgunned by the City. Voting is the the only thing we have. We may decide to fnd another way to live but the City will keep hoovering up the wealth, the only check is the electorate’s control of government.”

    But then the City and the government are not the same thing. The City does not seem to answer to the government, I don’t know if there is any party that is ready to implement the Robin Hood Tax or a similar measure. The financial industry have threatened to leave London if they don’t get their own way. We can’t vote out the people with real control of the money.

    “This coalition government will not hold firm for much longer and then it will have to deal, and with the voters fairly soon.”

    I am waiting patiently. 🙂 Never has a man committed political suicide quite so flamboyantly as Nick Clegg.

    “At the moment the banks own all political sides, but we are favoured by our geography. Being small and densely populated, the UK can generate popular political concensus quite easily, unlike America, which I believe will have an almighty struggle to regain the democracy that its utterly corrupt politicians have sold off.”

    The US scares me, although I don’t have the understanding of the whole situation that I would need to comment knowledgeably. I am scared at their attempts to roll back laws about abortion and a woman’s control of her own body. The story here about the woman arrested for miscarrying is chilling, as one example. From what I do understand though it seems they have one party who indulge in tabloidesque scare tactics in an attempt to wrest control from the other major party. It seems infantile and completely out of place in a modern democracy. I was honestly surprised when Obama was elected, although I am not sure whether he is living up to his promise or not. I am dismayed at the way some senators seem to carry on and at the fact that some families seem to have set themselves up like barons, expecting to be in power and privilege for generations because one of them got into office.

    I would like to know what the UK proposes to do to generate more income. The recent discussion of the continuing Greek crisis has highlighted the UK’s exposure to all of this debt. It seems trying to be a financial powerhouse is not enough to keep an economy going. Where is our manufacturing infrastructure? What industries do we have left except selling arms to other countries? (which doesn’t profit the UK as such as far as I can see, only the arms trade) I moved to Ireland at the start of this year (which will likely be next to be forced into more loans after Greece) and there is quite an emphasis here on buying Irish. I can’t recall the last time I heard a similar plea in the UK.

  4. Jane Osmond says:

    Hi Halla and Jane – both very interesting takes on the economic system we are labouring under at the moment – although I may disagree with trying to prevent the financial industry leaving London – I would call their bluff. And, if I lost, well then we might have to start making things and growing food in our own country again – how terrible would that be?

  5. Jane Da Vall says:

    Jane,

    I would call their bluff too. It is not at all easy to up sticks to Zurich or Shanghai. If it were, they would have done it already.  The problem with this government, and the next, whoever they are, is that they have no idea what they are doing.  The City accounts for a quarter of GDP, it has a small number of decisionmakers who communicate easily, and no-one in our political leadership knows how it works. If the chairman of Goldman Sachs says leave our bonuses alone or we’re off,  George Osborne has no idea if he is bluffing or not and cannot afford to be wrong.  

    By contrast, the US has a much broader based economy, the banks bought the politicians and the Supreme Court there instead.  I don’t know which route is the most effective, both are working well at present. 
     

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *