subscribe: Posts | Comments

German abuse case may challenge diplomatic immunity

1 comment

Summary of story from Der Spiegel, June 27, 2011

The case of a 30-year-old Indonesian woman working for a Saudi diplomat in Germany may make legal  history when it brings into question the issue of diplomatic immunity.

At least that is the hope of the German Institute of Human Rights, which is funding the case.

The woman worked for the Saudi family for more than a year and a half,  in a select neighbourhood of  Berlin, but claims she not only had to work unreasonable hours seven days a week, but she was also treated like a serf, kicked and beaten with a stick by her employer.

Labour protection laws in Germany are toothless when it comes to diplomats, who are shielded by the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations of 1961, which makes embassy employees untouchable.

They are immune from criminal prosecution, and civil suits against them are usually unwinnable. At worst, the Foreign Ministry can declare a diplomat persona non grata and force them to leave the country.

The intention behind such immunity was to safeguard diplomats from the arbitrary, state heavy-handedness or foreign laws.

But Nivedita Prasad, the head of Ban Ying, an organization based in Berlin that initially aimed to help prostitutes particularly from Asia, but more recently has been assisting foreign household employees of diplomats, hopes to see this diplomatic immunity challenged in Germany’s highest court.

Prasad has heard a lot of stories about what happens behind the polished facades of embassies, official residences and diplomats’ apartments. The stories include exploitation and harassment – and often even physical abuse.

Ban Ying and the German Institute of Human Rights want to make it possible to prosecute diplomats in instances of human rights violations, and are prepared to follow the case up to the Federal Constitutional Court, Germany’s highest legal body, or to the European Court of Human Rights.

  1. I support a petition to dismiss this criminal in his office!
    Please inform me more about this case!
    by @powerranger244

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *