subscribe: Posts | Comments

Horror as Daily Mail simplifies gender equality – again

8 comments

Summary of Sandra Parsons in Daily Mail, June 15 2011

This article doesn’t deserve much airtime, so I won’t take too long with it.

Pretty much everything you need to know about Sandra Parson’s viewpoint is contained in this quote:

“In the Western world, the feminist argument has been definitively won — and all the silly and, frankly, somewhat pathetic ‘slut walks’ in the world won’t refute that.”

I know what you’re thinking: this is political extremism gone mad – and you’re right (but not as far right as Sandra Parsons, ho ho).

If you insist on reading the rest of her article, I should  give you a trigger warning first. I do literally mean trigger – reading this made me want to shoot myself just to make the bad thoughts go away.

Let’s settle this in a really simple way: Gender inequality affects both sexes.

OK? Are we all clear on that now? Can I go home?

Just kidding, you know I’m not going to stop that early on in a rant.

There’s no point pitting one sex against the other, because we both lose.

And before the Daily Mail trolls descend on me with ‘But that’s what feminism does, you hate men’ – No it doesn’t and no I don’t, as my many male friends will testify gladly when I tell them they have to.

Gender inequality is increasing, and the impact of this can be seen across both sexes.

This is evidenced not only by the signs affecting boys and young men, for example in their educational achievement, which seems to be Sandra’s main evidence base, but also by the increasing sexualisation of girls and young women.

It is shown by the impact that increased access to hardcore pornography is having on the sexuality of boys and young men – a sexuality that is contrived, commodified and increasingly hostile to women.

No one wins here.

Sandra Parsons – along with, if you were paying attention yesterday, Beyonce – wants us to believe that the battle for gender equality for women has been won. Unlike Beyonce, however, Sandra wants you to believe that now it’s the boys that are suffering as a result.

But, as I wrote recently in these very pages, Slutwalk, far from being ‘pathetic’ or irrelevant, actually demonstrates the reality of gender equality.

The concept that women’s dress ‘provokes’ men to rape, sexual violence or harassment is based on a model of men as out of control of their own sexuality.

That’s not just offensive to women, it’s offensive to men, who are reduced to a caricature of themselves: dangerous animals panting after anything with a vaguely hourglass figure and at any time, only a few steps away from uncontrollably humping the leg of any woman who stands still long enough – or worse.

We hear a lot of rhetoric from our right wing friends – which for me is an oxymoron – that ‘We’re in it together’.

Where the Big Society is concerned, that’s absolute bullshit, but in terms of gender inequality, it couldn’t be more true.

And as such, gender inequality isn’t an either/or issue for men and women – it affects us all. And you don’t have to call yourself a feminist to realise that.

  1. A feminist = A person who believes men & women are equal in value and worth.
    Not – a man-hater. It’s not rocket science it’s a humane way of living.
    Daily mail never ceases to amaze the female reporters hate women.

  2. vicki wharton says:

    Stupid stupid troll – how the hell can she state that boys underachievement is anything other than as a result of the lads mag culture that saturates male media – working hard is passe and being responsible and doing your homework is seen as being a wimp. Its the attitude of their role models that needs to change, not give them even more positive discrimination than they already enjoy at school. I wonder how many mothers with four year old sons have had to speak to their child’s nursery about overtly negative attitudes to their child?

  3. jane.osmond says:

    Here is one Vicky – my son was completely turned off education in his reception year by a teacher who couldn’t cope with boys not sitting still. He went on through primary followed by this attitude from the wholly female staff and by the time he got to secondary school it was too late. He ended up in trouble and was the epitome of disaffected youth in every way. Then he did is plumbing qualification at FE college which was, unsurprisingly staffed wholly by men, and passed with flying colours. However, the experience at primary scarred him: i doubt whether he will ever go back into education. My take on his experience is that there should not be concentrations of gender in the teaching profession – there should be far more males in primary at the very least.

    • vicki wharton says:

      I would agree with you as regards having equal amounts of men in teaching, especially in primary level. My daughter is very physical though, a tomboy, as it used to be refered to, and that is primarily what she was getting into trouble over, her physicality, with the same misdemeanor being told off three times over by different teachers. Maybe what is needed is a different approach to physically active children whatever their gender, plus on her part she will need to learn to control some of her physicality as it can be distracting to others in the classroom – another life skill to be mastered!

      • Really interesting thread, Vicki and Jane, thanks.

        I too would love to see more men in teaching, and think this would do a lot to change education standards.

        The other interesting point about education is that when it was the other way around and girls were under-achieving, this wasn’t seen as a problem – except by feminists. But boys’ underachievement is seen more universally as a problem.

        As I argue here, I think pitting the sexes against one another is pointless, our social conditions are inextricably linked for one thing, and for another, everyone benefits when we work together. It’s impossible to effect real change for women without men understanding what damage the pattern’s of women’s oppression – as opposed to their liberation – do to them, too.

        In this, I’m really encouraged by the increasing number of men stepping up to campaign for a shift towards a fairer world for both men and women, and the increasing feeling that in this we can be ‘in it together’.

  4. Lesley says:

    In my experience, the reason that there are fewer male teachers in primary school in the uk is due to gender inequality, because male teachers are expected to aim higher in the teaching profession than primary level so they can support themselves and their families. In some european and international schools there is a greater balance of female/male staff in primary due to the higher qualifications required and the higher salaries paid and therefore the higher status and remuneration of the staff.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *