India’s elite, educated women ‘not welcome at green conferences’
Summary of story from The Telegraph, June 3, 2011
Jairam Ramesh, India’s minister of environment and forests, has suggested that the middle-class ‘English-speaking women’ who usually attend conferences on biodiversity and other green causes were useless compared with tribal women who had waged successful campaigns.
Speaking ahead of an event to mark World Environment Day on June 5, Mr Ramesh said educated ladies were “not required any more.”
“Sitting inside New Delhi’s main conference venue and listening to well-drafted speeches yields no results. This year we have invited about 100 tribal women from all over the country,” he said.
“Tribal women have done the maximum value addition to biodiversity and we should acknowledge and appreciate them,” he said.
His comments provoked outrage in feminists and socialites, who denounced them as ‘sexist.’
“I think this comment is outrageous. It seems he is picky. He has problems with the elite. Singling out English-speaking elite women is extremely unfortunate.”
“It’s the elite and educated women who promote environmental activities in and around the home and want to see such an environment around the world,” said Bina Ramani, a high-profile socialite.
“We have been trying to educate and empower uneducated women to keep their environment clean and live with better hygiene. Imagine after 10 years these tribal women, whom Jairam is calling the real stakeholders of the environment, start speaking English, will he also ignore them at that time?” she added.
WVoN comment: Hmmm – I applaud the inviting of tribal women to this kind of gathering, but can’t help but think that this rant against ‘middle-class ‘English-speaking women’ is rather sexist, even though there is a hint of noblesse oblige about their intentions. Surely there is room for both groups?











