subscribe: Posts | Comments

Scots laws on rape may be ineffective

1 comment

Summary of story from The Scotsman, prescription buy June 15, order 2011

Frank Mulholland, Scotland’s new Lord Advocate, has called into question the effectiveness of Scots law in prosecuting rape claims.

Scotland’s chief law officer said that the current Scottish legal system may not provide “effective sanctions” against rape, referring to the requirement to have at least two pieces of corroborating evidence before bringing a prosecution.

This is thought to be a significant deterrent to women when taking a case forward.

He also referred to the ruling in the Peter Cadder case, whereby police are prevented from interviewing a suspect without a lawyer present, as problematic.

Under current law, there are three key aspects of securing a conviction for rape: a police interview with the suspect, often resulting in an admission that intercourse had taken place; the prosecution proves that intercourse was not consensual; and the accused is aware that consent had not been given.

Mulholland said: “Following Cadder, we are in the position of having lost the first third of our case before we start because lawyers will tell their clients not to admit anything.

“Very often in rape cases there is a delay in reporting the offence, which means that the opportunity to gather forensic evidence is lost.

“The combined effect …could leave us in the position of falling foul of human rights law again.”

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I think the third requirement is problematic at the moment too – many men use the excuse that they ‘thought’ the women had consented – without bothering to check whether their own behaviour is designed to pressure the women into having sex when unpressurised, she wouldn’t. How many men use tactics such as aggressive sulking, insulting the women’s sex drive or looks, drugging her with alcohol etc to get sex. I think most men think these are legitimate psychological force to get what they want whereas I would argue that consent in these conditions is not really consent, its blackmailed consent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *