subscribe: Posts | Comments

Wal-Mart class action case rejected by US Supreme Court

0 comments

Summary of story from New York Times, June 20, 2011

The US Supreme Court has rejected a class action lawsuit against the supermarket chain Wal-Mart, which had been accused of discriminating against women in pay and promotions (see earlier WVoN story).

The case was the largest class action suit in American history. If successful, about 1.5 million women would have been eligible to receive back pay from the company, adding up to billions of dollars.

In a unanimous decision, the judges stated that the womens’ lawyers had used the class action rules improperly, and the case could not proceed as a collective lawsuit.

The judges did not rule on whether Wal-Mart had discriminated against the women.

However, in a broader question on the case, the judges were divided 5:4 on the further requirement for collective actions that ‘there are questions of law or fact common to the class.’

Justice Antonin Scalia said the plaintiffs could not demonstrate that they would receive ‘a common answer to the crucial question why was I disfavoured,’ and noted that Wal-Mart had policies in place forbidding discrimination.

The plaintiffs sought the testimony of sociology professor William T. Bielby, who argued that various factors, including the significant discretion given to store managers in personnel decisions, allowed unconsciously-held stereotypes to affect their choices.

Justice Scalia rejected Professor Bielby’s testimony, ruling that ‘it is worlds away from “significant proof” that Wal-Mart “operated under a general policy of discrimination.”‘

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *