Agricultural development and the roots of inequality
Summary of story from The Economist, July 21, 2011
A new paper by Alberto Alesina and Nathan Nunn of Harvard University and Paola Giuliano of the University of California, Los Angeles, finds striking evidence that ancient agricultural techniques have very long-lasting effects.
Fernand Braudel (1902-1985), a renowned French historian, once described a remarkable transformation in the society of ancient Mesopotamia.
Sometime before the end of the fifth millennium BC, the fertile region between the Tigris and the Euphrates went from being one that worshipped “all-powerful mother goddesses” to one where it was “the male gods and priests who were predominant in Sumer and Babylon.”
The cause of this move from matriarchy, Braudel argued, was neither a change in law nor a wholesale reorganisation of politics. Rather, it was a fundamental change in the technology the Mesopotamians used to produce food: the adoption of the plough.
The plough was heavier than the tools formerly used by farmers. By demanding significantly more upper-body strength than hoes did, it gave men an advantage over women.
Long after most people have stopped tilling the land for a living, the economists find, their views about the economic role of women seem to line up with whether their ancestors ploughed or whether they hoed.
Women descended from plough-users are less likely to work outside the home, to be elected to parliament or to run businesses than their counterparts in countries at similar levels of development who happen to be descended from hoe-users.
The research reinforces the ideas of Ester Boserup, an economist who argued in the 1970s that cultural norms about the economic roles of the sexes can be traced back to traditional farming practices.
The data show that ethnic groups whose ancestors would have been expected to pick ploughs based on climatic conditions have sharply differentiated economic roles for the sexes even today. So it seems reasonable to argue that its use drove attitudes rather than the other way around.
The economists offer a final piece of evidence that suggests that agricultural history still affects people’s beliefs. Using data from the World Values Survey, they show that descendants of plough-users are significantly more likely to agree with a statement that men should have first claims on jobs when unemployment is high.
They also tend to agree that men make better political leaders.
Such beliefs survive immigration: the authors find that the daughters of immigrants to America are less likely to work if their parents came from a traditionally plough-based society.
WVoN comment: It surprised me that the article didn’t mention Engels’ “Origin of the family, private property, and the state”. First published in 1884 it provides a socialist critique of the evolution of agriculture and the attitudes it nurtured.
Over 100 years later it is still an incredibly useful book.
As the researchers point out, the root of gender inequality is in attitude and attitude certainly doesn’t last forever. However, it does seem to be painstakingly shoehorned down the generations.
What Engels does is to trace how the standards of patriarchal, monogamous family were tightened up by the increase in agricultural production and output (with thanks to the plough), laying the foundations for a class society, where everybody knew their place, especially women.
Gender inequality is a product of society and is manifested within countless ideas and institutions. Inequality cannot be truly changed without dismantling class society. Class society cannot be dismantled without swinging our economic priorities away from capitalism.
It is essential to look at the whole picture when trying to analyse and understand historical developments. Industry (by which I mean modes and means of production), economics, social policy, justice etc. cannot be abstracted from one another.
To move forward we need to challenge the structure as a whole and the “integrity” on which it presumes it is based.












