subscribe: Posts | Comments

Anti-abortion views of doctors may impact on women’s access to services

1 comment

Summary of story from The Guardian, July 18, 2011

A survey in the Journal of Medical Ethics of  733 medical students in the UK has found that nearly half believe they should be allowed to refuse to carry out a procedure they disagree with on moral, cultural or religious grounds, including abortions.

According to researcher, Dr Sophie Strickland, a third of the medical students said that they would choose not to carry out an abortion on a congenitally malformed foetus after 24 weeks gestation, a quarter would not perform the procedure after a contraception failure before 24 weeks, and a fifth would refuse to terminate a pregnancy on a minor who had been the victim of rape.

Strickland is concerned that an increasing demand for abortions, and the anti-abortion views of a growing number of doctors, could create access problems for abortion services.

Ann Furedi, of the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, says that medical students are not required to engage with the reasons why women might want to have an abortion, and that abortion is being taught increasingly infrequently in medical schools.

The Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology have also expressed their concern that more and more medical students are choosing to opt out of training in the termination of pregnancy.

The chair of the General Medical Council, Peter Rubin said that, while their guidance states that doctors should be able to refer patients onto a colleague if they object to a particular procedure or treatment, doctors have an overriding duty to their patients and that it is ‘not acceptable to opt out of treating a particular patient or group of patients because of personal beliefs or views about them’.

The British Medical Association and the Department of Health said that doctors and medical students may choose to opt out of treatments they feel uncomfortable with, but patients must not be harmed or affected by their decision.

  1. I’ve heard that fewer students are being trained on this in the US, I am alarmed that it is also the case in the UK. Elective abortions are not the only application of this set of skills though, are they? Doctors are being trained with dangerous gaps in their knowledge it seems.

    I know midwives discuss abortion and their assistance while in training. For myself I feel that it’s one of those things that, if it’s such a big moral problem, perhaps the person concerned should reconsider their career choice as I can’t think of any other careers that someone gets to choose to do only the bits that they agree with and ignore the other tasks – in fact, *condemn* the other tasks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *