Bangladesh must protect women against ‘fatwa’ violence
Summary of story from Human Rights Watch, July 6, 2011
The Bangladesh government must take urgent action to ensure religious fatwas and traditional measures of dispute resolution do not result in extrajudicial punishments, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said this week.
Despite repeated Supreme Court orders to stop illegal punishments such as whipping, lashings and public humiliations, the government has yet to act.
In 2009 Ain-o-Salish Kendra (ASK), Bangladesh Legal Aid and Services Trust, BRAC, Bangladesh Mahila Parishad and Nijera Kori brought a public interest case.
They challenged the failure of the authorities to address extrajudicial punishments imposed by shalishes – traditional dispute resolution methods – in the name of fatwas, opinions that are supposed to be issued by Islamic scholars.
The punishments include whipping, lashing, publicly humiliating women by blackening their faces or cutting their hair, imposing fines and ostracizing women. ASK has collected reports of at least 330 incidents in the last 10 years.
Aruna Kashyap, Asia women’s rights researcher at HRW said: “These private punishments significantly harm women’s and girls’ lives and health. Instead of intervening and taking active measures to prevent these abuses, the Bangladesh authorities have been mute bystanders.”
A court order was issued in July 2010, following the case of adolescent Hena Akhter who was given 100 lashes in January for an alleged affair by a shalish in Shariatpur district in the Dhaka division.
Despite accounts that she had reported being sexually assaulted, Akhter collapsed during the lashing and ultimately died. The local media has reported three suicides of girls following similar punishments.
The High Court division of the Supreme Court issued its judgement in the case on 8 July, which criticised the Bangladesh government for not protecting its citizens from cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment.
The court directed the government to investigate and prosecute those responsible and to take preventive steps through awareness campaigns in schools, colleges and madrasas.
The court also instructed the Ministry of Local Government to inform all law enforcement and local government officials that extrajudicial punishments are criminal offences.
Additional orders, issued by the High Court and Supreme Court in February and May 2011 respectively, further enforced the ruling and urged the government to publicise it through electronic and print media.
Commenting on the Supreme Court’s verdict that “no punishment, including physical violence and/or mental torture in any form can be imposed or inflicted on anybody in pursuance of fatwa”, Sara Hossain, a lawyer involved in the case said that women’s rights groups were relieved to see the highest court strongly condemning extrajudicial punishments in the name of fatwas.
However, she noted that women’s rights activists in Bangladesh remain concerned that the door had been left open for fatwas to be issued, threatening women’s rights to equality.











