DJ apologises in breast feeding row
Summary of story from the Sun, July 23, 2011
The BBC has been made to apologise after a radio host compared women breastfeeding in public to him having sex with his wife in a restaurant.
A guest on James Hazell’s Radio Suffolk show called breastfeeding in public “the most natural thing in the world”.
Hazell retorted: “Next time you are out having a meal at a restaurant, on the basis that it is the most natural thing in the world, I will come in there with my wife and then make love right in front of you.
“You say it’s the most natural thing in the world, but there are a lot of natural things we don’t do in public.”
Furious mum-of-two Laura Cardwell, from Ipswich, said: “I was appalled. There is nothing more natural than nursing your baby.”
A BBC spokesman said the comment was aimed to “stimulate debate”, adding: “We apologise if James Hazell’s comments caused offence to some of the audience.”
WVoN Comment: Hmm, I always find myself conflicted when breastfeeding is mentioned – not because I think women shouldn’t breastfeed in public – but because, as a failed breastfeeder myself, I instinctively resent what I perceive to be the righteous tone that is routinely employed by the breastfeeding movement.
















As a failed breastfeeder myself, I am one of those who advocate women being allowed to feed their babies in public. It is natural, it is beautiful & why should anyone be prevented form nourishing a baby in public. People moan when babies cry, they moan when babies are fed. Surely these infants are the future not something to be frowned upon at every opportunity.
Are.these moaning people the same folk who tell children off for playing?
Babies & children need more acceptance, nurturing & patience.
It’s unfortunate that women like the author who tried to breastfeed and could not feel that they have ‘failed’. Most ‘failures’ are the result of lack of support, either from partners, wider family, health professionals or society at large as typified by Mr Hazell’s comments. We have become very far removed from breastfeeding being the normal and natural way to feed our children. While some lactivists may bang the drum for breastfeeding a little too vehemently, it is a shame that those of us who seek to celebrate and support breastfeeding are also labelled as ‘righteous’. We are not, we are just trying to help those who want it.
Hi Emma – yes I was made to feel as though I had failed because I couldn’t breastfeed. To be fair, it was 22 years ago and there was very little support available then, just a ‘breast feeding is best’ message, so ‘you better get on with it’. Also, I do question the practicality of breastfeeding for those of us who return to work within the first 6 months, and think that practicality and how some women really live their lives is not something that is taken into consideration by the breastfeeding lobby.
My mum tells me of how they’d have to dash back from a night out when I was a baby so that I could be fed – I didn’t like bottles at all. I know from experience that just pumping breast milk may not ensure a proper supply so it may not be practical to express and store either. And then there’s the fights mothers have to get somewhere clean and secluded to express at work.
Did anyone else see the case in the US of the breastfeeding mother who was held up by TSA agents because she’d had the audacity to check whether breast milk as an exempt substance from the liquid restrictions on flights? Slight tangent, but an example of how barriers are placed in the path of women who just want to get on with feeding their offspring.
Crazy! Another person who has confused the real function of breasts with sex.
And on the topic of “failed breastfeeders” – we wouldn’t have failure if girls grew up seeing breastfeeding everywhere, and new moms were surrounded by a community of breastfeeding. Hopefully I don’t sound too self-righteous!
I’m a failed breastfeeder too. My twins did get breastmilk after they were born, down their nasal tubes. But anyway.
Jame’s Hazell was out of line with that comment. As far as I know we don’t have any particular taboo about eating in public, so why should babies be different? It sounds like he’s made the mistake of viewing breasts as leisure items for the use of men, as so many people seem to do.