subscribe: Posts | Comments

DNA queries bring fresh hope for Amanda Knox

0 comments

Summary of story from the Observer, July 24, 2011

Today will be the first of three hearings to review the DNA forensic evidence in the Amanda Knox case currently being heard in a court in Italy (see WVoN coverage).

Knox was convicted in 2009 of the murder of British student Meredith Kercher, along with her former boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito and a third suspect, Rudy Guede, who had already been convicted of the killing.

Now a report, written by two independent experts from Rome’s Sapienza University, is to be legally and scientifically scrutinised in Knox’s appeal against her conviction.

The 145-page DNA review rubbishes the work of Patrizia Stefanoni, the police forensic scientist who found Knox’s and Kercher’s DNA on a kitchen knife at Sollecito’s house and identified DNA belonging to Sollecito on a torn bra clasp found beside Kercher’s body.

The report claims Stefanoni ignored international DNA protocols, made basic errors and gave evidence in court that was not backed up by her laboratory work, rendering the knife and bra strap worthless as evidence.

After discovering there was no DNA left to check on the knife or the bra clasp, the expert authors retraced the steps taken by Stefanoni, concluding that the DNA trace of Kercher on the blade was so weak it could not be reliably matched – or was at best the result of contamination.

They also quoted Stefanoni admitting in court she should have double-tested her result to be more convincing.

Stefanoni claimed she had no need to repeat tests since the experts for the defence were on hand to witness her work. “And it was good enough to show it was Kercher’s DNA,” she said. “A small amount, but good quality.”

The experts quote numerous US police and FBI experts on the risk of low DNA results and poor evidence handling, prompting one Italian police source to claim they were being fed information by Knox’s defence team.

The three days of DNA hearings, today, 30th July and 1st August, will be followed in September by final arguments. The verdict is now expected around 25th September.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *