Elizabeth Warren: government’s mortgage abuse investigation is not sufficient
Summary of story from HuffPost AOL News, July 15, 2011
Elizabeth Warren – a senior adviser to President Barack Obama and Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner – told a congressional panel on Thursday that government agencies may not have sufficiently investigated foreclosure abuses.
The investigations were launched last year amid news reports that lenders were at times improperly repossessing borrowers’ homes and breaking state laws and federal rules in the process.
Warren, the temporary custodian of the new federal agency the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection, has long questioned whether the state and federal probes have been comprehensive.
She is the first senior administration official to publicly question the thoroughness of the investigations led by the Justice Department, the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the Treasury Department, Federal Trade Commission, all 50 state attorneys general and more than 30 state bank regulators.
According to a confidential presentation prepared for state attorneys general by Warren’s agency, large banks have reaped tremendous benefits from under-serving distressed homeowners, a complaint frequent enough among borrowers that federal regulators have acknowledged the industry has fundamental shortcomings, including a penchant to abuse borrowers, and is in need of reform.
State and federal prosecutors are preparing to settle with five banks – the largest mortgage services in the country – concerning the accusations that they abused homeowners and broke various laws in exchange for penalties and mortgage relief for struggling borrowers, even though they’ve only initiated a limited investigation that hasn’t examined the full extent of the alleged wrongdoing.
The state officials could push for expanded investigative powers, but they would likely face a hard slog in court.
A 2009 US Supreme Court case, Cuomo v Clearing House, restricts state attorneys general from subpoenaing documents from national banks until they’ve filed lawsuits.
Another from 2007 — Watters v Wachovia determined that state officials lack the authority to regulate subsidiaries of national banks, based on a policy known as preemption.
A thorough probe would likely take more than a year. Meanwhile, the housing market remains depressed as foreclosures continue to pile up, borrowers are falling behind at elevated rates and the so-called “shadow inventory” of distressed homes being kept off the market grows.











