subscribe: Posts | Comments

Former Rwanda minister guilty of rape and genocide

1 comment

Summary of story from Human Rights Watch, July 22, 2011

Last month the International Criminal Tribunal found Pauline Nyiramasuhuko guilty of war crimes (see WVoN story).

Rwanda’s former minister for family and women’s affairs is the first woman to ever be found guilty of genocide.

Additionally she was convicted of war crimes, crimes against humanity, including rape, for her role in planning and ordering others to carry out these crimes during Rwanda’s 1994 genocide.

It might be uncomfortable to deal with the fact that women can plan and direct violence, but Nyiramasuhuko’s conviction, particularly for rape, should be celebrated as a big step forward for women’s rights.  There are two reasons for this.

First, it contributes directly to justice for sexual violence – one of the least prosecuted crimes in the world.

To be sure there is more empathy surrounding sexual violence in war, perhaps because victims are seen as genuinely “innocent”.

Despite this it took decades after the adoption of the Geneva Conventions, in which sexual violence was defined as an attack on a person’s dignity, before the adoption of the Rome statute of the International Criminal Court, which defines and adds context to the different types of sexual violence in conflict.

While only a fraction of war crimes may ever be persecuted, it has been noted that rape continues to be underprosecuted for a number of reasons, including the victims’ reluctance to speak up, the general difficulties in collecting information and proving coercion.

Therefore thoughtful jurisprudence on rape in war and including it on an equal basis with the other crimes Nyiramasuhuko was accused of helps overcome this gap and this should be celebrated.

Second, Nyiramasuhuko’s conviction counters the most overused and dangerous justification for rape in war: “Boys will be boys”- suggesting that male soldiers will rape female civilians because of uncontrollable genetic impulses to have sex.

Nyiramasuhuko’s conviction and everything that is known about sexual violence as a weapon of war, points to how wrong this concept is (see WVoN story).

Systematic rape is an effective way to terrorize a civilian population and destroy the social fabric that would later lead to reconstruction.  It is used as a weapon of war and therefore is ordered (or wilfully ignored) by commanders and superiors- even if the superiors are women, like Nyiramasuhuko.

If this conviction contributes to overcoming the boys-will-be-boys way of thinking, then perhaps it will contribute to the end of the insulting notion that men just can’t control themselves.

Surely, until we all accept responsibility for our actions, as conscious, thinking human beings, there can be neither peace nor justice.

  1. “It might be uncomfortable to deal with the fact that women can plan and direct violence” – why? I wouldn’t have expected in 2011 that the idea women can be violent, and horribly so, is still so transgressive. Women are still not often in a position of such power that violence on this scale is possible, but I wonder if there would be much difference between male and female leaders if there were equal numbers of both. Which is a sad thing to wonder about, really.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *