Prosecutor says not to drop requirement for corroboration in Scottish rape cases
Summary of story from BBC, July 27, 2011
The head of Europe’s first specialist unit investigating serious sex crimes has said politicians must be cautious in considering changes to the way rape cases are handled in Scotland.
Derek Ogg, who has stepped down from his role as senior prosecutor in Scotland’s National Sex Crimes Unit, warned against ending the requirement for corroboration in rape cases, currently being considered by the Scottish government.
Scotland, however, has been criticised for having one of Europe’s lowest conviction rates – around 3%.
He said: “The great thing about protections in our law – it needn’t be corroboration, it might be other types of protections, I’m not married to corroboration – the great thing about protections in our law is it means that no-one can go to jail just on a pointed finger.”
He added: “It’s not just being convicted. A pointed finger of sexual impropriety can destroy someone’s livelihood, their reputation.
He added: “So we take very seriously the responsibility we have before launching an allegation, a prosecution or asking a jury for a conviction.”
Instead, he says the way rape allegations are investigated from the first complaint is key to improving conviction rates – and praises the Archway Centre in Glasgow.
Operating 24 hours a day, Scotland’s only “one-stop shop” for victims of serious sex crimes has seen its number of referrals rise by up to 60% in the past 12 months.











