The dress code barrier for Muslim women in sports
Summary of story from Altmuslimah.com, thumb July 17, clinic 2011
Last month, sales debates about how religious dress codes can impact on the participation of women in competitive sports were fuelled by a number of different sporting events.
In one case, the female weightlifter Kulsoom Abdullah was initially barred from the US championships, because she wanted to compete in clothing that would cover her elbows and knees in accordance with her interpretation of Islamic rules of modesty for women.
Officials were concerned that such clothing would obscure the view of the judges to assess whether she had achieved a proper “lock” of the elbows and knees, which is essential for a weight-lifting competition.
So, Abdullah proposed to wear a tight fitting unitard under the compulsory competition costume, which would allow the judges to assess whether her elbows and knees were properly locked while lifting weights.
The International Weightlifting Federation agreed to this compromise and Abdullah then registered for the US Championships.
The case that garnered most of the media attention, however, involved the Iranian women’s soccer team. The women were not allowed to play a qualifying match for the 2012 Olympics because of a dress code ruling made by FIFA officials (see WVoN story).
FIFA had previously allowed Muslim women soccer players to use hair caps as a compromise so that they could comply with Muslim requirements for covering their hair. However, the Iranian soccer team appeared in a full body tracksuit that not only covered their hair with a cap but also covered their neck and ears.
According to a FIFA official, the Iranian delegation had previously signaled understanding of the FIFA rule, but apparently chose to violate it.
Many commentators saw the FIFA ruling as an infringement on the religious freedom of Muslim women by an international secular organization and as a punitive decision that would set back the progress of Muslim women athletes.
As pointed out by the human rights activist Dokhi Fassihian, it is difficult to invoke personal religious freedom in the case of Iran, as the Iranian government mandates a certain religious dress-code for all women. The reasons cited by FIFA are somewhat confusing.
The officials have referred to concerns about the safety of the women playing soccer in tight headscarves that also cover the neck (hijab) and may cause choking injuries.
But officials have also pointed out that, according to FIFA regulations: “Players and officials shall not display political, religious, commercial or personal messages or slogans in any language or form on their playing or team kits.”
It is not clear if head-coverings for women are indeed seen as a religious or political symbol or why FIFA had previously permitted female Muslim soccer players to wear the caps.
Furthermore, the fact that the head of FIFA, Sepp Blatter, has previously made misogynistic comments about how women soccer players need to wear tighter shorts, also raises questions about the true motivations behind the FIFA decision.
Secular observers may not always understand that for many Muslim women, the dress code and hijab have taken on a tremendous religious significance.
For some Muslim women, wearing hijab has become a core aspect of their faith and how they define themselves.
For the Muslim women who feel that wearing the hijab and abiding by a certain dress code is mandatory according to their faith, absolute bans on hijab and other dress restrictions by sports organizations could strongly deter them from participating in competitive sports.
Looking forward, it is apparent that religious communities and secular sports organizations will need to continue to work on compromises that ensure maximum female participation in sports, both at the amateur and professional level.
When countries like Iran mandate a certain religious dress code for all women, it may be very difficult for an international sports organization to modify its dress code rules for participants.
After all, it is impossible to determine whether these athletes are being coerced into wearing a certain dress by their governments or whether it is truly a matter of a personal religious choice.











