subscribe: Posts | Comments

Victims of trafficking will “no longer be treated as criminals”

0 comments

Summary of story from the Guardian, July 3, 2011

Women and children who have been trafficked into the UK will no longer be treated as criminals according to new guidance from the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).

The move reflects ongoing concerns of charity campaigners that victims of trafficking continue to be wrongly prosecuted.

It would also bring the UK in line with an EU directive which outlines that where victims have been compelled to commit crime, the state must not prosecute them.

The advice now is that cases should be dropped where there is a suspicion that a child engaged in criminal activity has been trafficked. Additionally, prosecutors will no longer need evidence to show how children were trafficked before treating them as victims rather than criminals.

The CPS wants to encourage more victims to speak out about their traffickers, in the hope of boosting conviction rates, said Pam Bowen, CPS policy adviser on trafficking. Between 2004 and 2009, just 48 people were convicted of trafficking offences in England and Wales.

The US state department recently complained that the British government was not doing enough to address trafficking for domestic servitude in foreign diplomatic missions in London.

There have been 19 recent cases of alleged trafficking of domestic workers by diplomats. These were reported to the government’s anti-trafficking agency by the charity Kalayaan.

But one leading campaigner for the rights of victims suggested the new advice for prosecutors did not go far enough.

“For a long time Britain has criminalised victims of trafficking and this continues to be the case particularly [with] people trafficked to work in cannabis farms,” said Chris Beddoe, director of ECPAT UK, a group campaigning against child abuse and trafficking.

“These new guidelines include some distinct improvements but they don’t place any mandatory responsibility to safeguard children … it remains dependent on somebody bringing a suspect’s possible status as a victim of trafficking to the attention of the prosecutor.

“We think the CPS should take a more pro-active approach than that.”

The CPS said it had told prosecutors to listen to the views of charities and NGOs, who work directly with suspected victims, rather than just the police.

The number of prosecutions for trafficking for sexual exploitation alone are about 100 a year. Operation Golf, a police operation aimed at a Romanian criminal gang suspected of trafficking 181 children into the UK for begging and theft, has led to 85 convictions in British courts, but only four were for trafficking offences.

The CPS have said they recongised some women were scared of going to court because they feared retribtuion from their traffickers. They hope that securing women’s status as victims rather than criminals will make it easier to obtain intelligence.

For further WVoN discussion on trafficking and UK legislation please click here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *