subscribe: Posts | Comments

What stories do we really want to hear about women?

0 comments

Summary of story from Ms Blog, July 27, 2011

An interesting post on the Ms Magazine blog today asks how relevant many of the stories the media publishes about prominent women actually are.

Using the example of a recent ‘scoop’ by Washington Post reporter Natalie Jennings “Michelle Obama Orders 1,700-calorie meal at Shake Shack“, writer Christie Thompson claims that it was but one of a number of similar stories to hit the pages of ‘serious’ papers in recent days.

Another obvious example is the focus on Rebekah Brooks (former chief exec of News International) and the deliberate, or otherwise, emphasis of her mane of wavy auburn hair.

It is clear that the reporters on these stories consider they have an important point to make.

Michelle Obama has used her influence to promote a healthy lifestyle for the next generation of Americans, and there is little doubt a fast food meal is not as good for you as a chicken salad. But when did a healthy lifestyle exclude an occasional treat?

Similarly, reporters have focused on the potentially distracting effect of Brooks’ hair as she gives evidence to politicians, and potentially, juries.

However, she has had this hairstyle for many years. Is this really a valid critique of her as a journalist? There are surely many other criticisms that can be levelled at her, and would a man be subject to the same examination of his appearance?

Thompson suggests that while we expect celebrity magazines to post stories that are less than ‘real’ news, it is disturbing when ‘heavier’ media outlets like the Washington Post seems to follow suit.

WVoN comment: I agree. Perhaps we can anticipate that The Sun will provide a cut out Rebekah Brooks wig to offer a reader instant protection from any sort of punishment.

But if these ‘non-news’ items spread beyond the boundaries of the tabloid press then our confidence in news presentation relating to women will be further damaged.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *