subscribe: Posts | Comments

Another study confirms male-female math gap to be cultural

0 comments

Summary of story from Time, August 30, 2011.

A new study of two tribes from rural India sheds light on the roots of gender differences in math performance.

The study offers further evidence to support the claim that cultural differences have a large impact on performance, and that biology alone does not determine women’s math aptitude.

Researchers led by Moshe Hoffman, a postdoctoral fellow at the University of California, San Diego, studied members of the Khasi and Karbi tribes of India.

Both are highly similar genetically, both are subsistence farmers.

Culturally, however, they are quite different. The Karbi are patrilineal. The Khasi are practically matriarchal.

Hoffman studied people from both Khasi and Karbi villages, testing their ability to solve block puzzles.

Among the male-dominated Karbi, men were 36 per cent faster at solving block puzzles than women. But among the Khasi, the difference between men and women was so small that it was not statistically significant.

Questions have been raised on the limitations of the study, namely that the puzzle test did not include the rotation of figures, but such tests were not used in this case because the abstract objects would have been too unfamiliar to the Indian tribes.

The study was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

WVoN comment: Critics raise issues with studies that disprove cultural stereotypes, but fail to apply the same standards to studies that confirm them.

The absence of a spatial-rotation test will be used as evidence of the study’s limitations.

However, I question the importance of the spatial-rotation test itself: why do researchers assume that the ability to visualise the rotation of a three-dimensional object and project that rotation on a two-dimensional piece of paper is indicative of people’s aptitude at maths?

And the fact that such a test was “too abstract” for the villagers would indicate that it is not a useful tool for measuring basic human visual-spatial skills.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *