subscribe: Posts | Comments

Bachmann and Palin, the wide appeal of right-wing feminism

1 comment

Summary of story from Business Insider, sildenafil August 1, and 2011

Despite their regular derision in the mainstream press, both Michelle Bachmann and Sarah Palin are enjoying substantial levels of popular support, but why?

What do they have that other candidates don’t – and that so many Americans seem to want?

The nature of their attraction has to do with two strains in American thought to which the US left and media establishment are truly blind.

One is the American tradition of populist demagoguery. Populist leaders inspire passionate devotion, usually in people who feel (and often are) economically, politically, and culturally marginalized.

They use emotive rhetoric. They create an “us versus them” scenario. And they ask their listeners to believe that they alone will restore American dignity and articulate the wishes of the unheard.

Palin and Bachmann speak this highly personal or emotional language, which even the most rock-ribbed male Republican finds difficult to emulate.

In the last three decades, America’s male-dominated politics has become increasingly wonky, abstract, and professionalized.

This is bad for demagoguery, but it does not inhibit the tigresses on the right, who did not come up through the “old boy’s club”.

The second reason that Bachmann and Palin appeal to so many Americans has to do with a serious historical misreading of feminism.

Feminism in the 1960s and 1970s was articulated via the institutions of the left. In Britain, it was often allied with the labour movement, and in America, it was reborn in conjunction with the emergence of the New Left.

However, feminism is philosophically as much in harmony with conservative, and especially libertarian, values – and in some ways even more so.

The core of feminism is individual choice and freedom, and it is these strains that are being sounded now more by the Tea Party movement than by the left.

But, apart from these sound bites, there is a powerful constituency of right-wing women in Britain and Western Europe, as well as in America, who do not see their values reflected in collectivist social-policy prescriptions or gender quotas.

Many of these women are socially conservative, strongly supportive of the armed forces, and religious – and yet they crave equality as strongly as any leftist vegetarian in Birkenstocks.

It is blindness to this perfectly legitimate approach to feminism that keeps tripping up commentators who wish to dismiss women like Margaret Thatcher, or Muslim women, or now right-wing US women leaders, as somehow not being the “real thing”.

But these women are real feminists even if they do not share policy preferences with the already recognized “sisterhood,” and even if they themselves would reject the feminist label, we ignore the wide appeal of right-wing feminism at our peril.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *