Call for rethink of family social policy, not ‘show trials’
Summary of story from The Guardian, August 15, 2011
Deborah Orr argues in this opinion piece that the ‘show trials’ currently going on in Britain’s courtrooms are not a solution to the recent riots, and that the left in particular needs to rethink the future of family social policy.
She also appeals to the left to confront the issue of young women having children with inadequate support.
“There was outrage when the last Labour government floated the idea of residential centres for young mothers who chose to start families without being able to provide material support to them.”
Maybe, she says, this should be looked at again.
There should, she writes, be an obligation regularly to attend the nursery sections of family therapy units, which could take over the baby and toddler services and clinics offered by the NHS.
Maybe, she continues, if you want to make the ambitiously reckless and highly risky commitment of having a child whom you cannot house or support without state help, there should be some strings.
The left, she says, “has to face the fact that living off the state, when you are able-bodied, able-minded, educated and young, is something that does need some stigma attached to it.”
















This is just the Spawn of Laddism – Loaded’s front cover recently celebrated 20 years of ‘getting away with it’ and that’s exactly what they have groomed the male population into doing – celebrating breaking the rules rather than upholding them. That, in conjunction with a diet of junk food, cheap clothing, poor housing, no job prospects, an addiction to violent, sadistic sex via the internet and violent, sadistic behaviour towards others through Call of Duty and other war games has left them with the impression that they themselves are the only authority they respect – and that’s shaky.
This… turned into a really long train of thought type comment. Feel free to skip. 🙂
Reading the article about Nuts magazine I’ve been pondering whether getting what we want, when we want, is a healthy way for society to function (spoiler: no). That article said they asked boys/men from 16-24 what they wanted in a magazine. At the risk of portraying a stereotype, 16-y-o boys, having discovered that they are sexual beings and that they (in general) enjoy looking at scantily clad people (again, in general, women) are being served up their greatest fantasies easily from such magazines and the net. No effort is required bar maybe spending a couple of quid. So they are turned into consumers, spoonfed. No incentive to improve, or grow past that stage.
Womens’ mags, on the other hand, urge us to strive to attain something we can’t, ever (‘The Perfect’ whatever it is) and trade in making us feel rotten that we can’t get it, but we might if we buy the right things.
So we’re encouraged to consume, to expect our desires to be gratified. We’re generally discouraged from learning by being told that the arts and humanities have no (financial) worth, being shown only the most controversial examples of modern art (half a cow, anyone? Diamond-encrusted skull? Perhaps some graffiti then?) and that exams are getting easier all the time. People have made fortunes by being on TV programmes and having a small army of stylists etc. turn them into consumer products. If we do navigate all this then there are few jobs (but a huge range of qualifications required for them).
And *again* women are being scrutinised for daring to take the ‘risky step’ of reproducing. Maybe there is some value in the proposals mentioned above but trying to blame or shame people into participating just calls to my mind the Magdalene laundries and we should never return to that model.
Is it possible to be liberal-leaning and also desire a recognition that discipline (self, ideally) is good for humans?
I think it is possible and is found within the church to some extent but unfortunately in throwing out the worst of the church we have thrown out the best too. I think your points above are all really valid and am also deeply uncomfortable with a society that makes up the punishment after the crime – that feels like meeting one wrong with another which I think is called ‘escalating’ in councelling circles and will likely lead to more anger rather than less.
Absolutely. Once the state effectively gives their approval to stigmatise a group on the basis of one shared characteristic then it opens the gate to all sorts of abuses and persecutions. Shaming doesn’t work as a long term driver of change.