Corporation sues employee for bringing “frivolous” claim of rape
Summary of story from Feministing, August 24, 2011
A woman who lost her case last month against defence contractor, KBR, for creating a hostile work environment after she was raped while working for them in Iraq, is now being sued by the company for legal costs.
Jamie Leigh Jones claims she was drugged and raped by a group of colleagues while working for the defence contractor. After deliberating for ten hours, the jury rejected her case that the company was guilty of negligence.
KBR is now suing Jones for $2 (US) million in legal fees on the ground that her claims were “fabricated and frivolous”.
“They have beaten us and now they are attempting to crush us. This is an attempt by KBR to chill other people from bringing claims against them,” said Jones’s lawyer.
The law suit sparked other women working for defence contractors in Iraq to come forward with stories of sexual assault and corporate indifference.
KBR claim that the “mandatory arbitration clause” Jones signed when she went to work for them meant that the rape charge had to be resolved in a private, internal arbitration and not a court of law.
In 2009, Senator Al Franken, prohibited the Defence Department from hiring companies that use arbitration to resolve cases of sexual assault, battery, or racial discrimination (see WVoN story)
KBR’s lawyers defended the move saying, “Our fees were substantial, so we’d like to get reimbursed.”
















Note that it doesn’t say the jury found she had made up the claim, only that KBR were not negligent. And then they get to sue her. Big businesses, aren’t they smashing.
It’s the American system.
KBR wasn’t negligent in personal matters.
She lost the case based on the claims that
she made, so they are going after her in
order to recover some money.
Standard tactic really.
They are also saying that her claims were ‘fabricated and frivolous’ – that goes a bit beyond being found not negligent. As they are a large company and can afford expensive lawyers in the first place this is a particularly ugly move against an individual and I can’t help but agree that it is both punitive and designed to deter anyone else who would dare to stand up to them.
Not really, typically it’s normal to throw in as many charges as possible, including the kitchen sink, within US civil trials.
Who benefits?
The corporation if they do it right. BUT, this will be brought before a jury, a civil trial jury anyhow. So, it’s quite likely, they’ll back down and sign off for some small insignificant sum, and a non disclosure agreement.