subscribe: Posts | Comments

Post-riot advice to magistrates may explain prison term for gift of shorts

1 comment

Summary of story from The Guardian, August 15, 2011

Magistrates in England have been advised to “disregard normal sentencing” so that cases which usually would be dealt with by magistrates courts could now be referred to crown court for tougher sentences.

The sentencing advice from Her Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) came to light after the chair of Camberwell Green magistrates court, Novello Noades, claimed that the court had been given a government “directive” that anyone involved in the rioting be given a custodial sentence.

She later retracted her statement and said she was mortified to have used the term “directive”.

Clarifying what had occurred, HMCTS explained that a senior clerk had circulated instructions to court clerks that they should advise magistrates to consider disregarding normal sentencing guidelines.

This may explain why some of those convicted have received punitive sentences for offences that might normally attract a far shorter term.

In Manchester, for example, a woman was jailed for five months for receiving a pair of shorts given to her after they had been looted from a city centre store.

  1. So far the sentencing for this seems to be very harsh. Two men were jailed for four years for having tried (and failed) online to encourage people to riot. This case too. I’m alarmed by this and wonder how long people will serve and whether this sentencing will cause further problems. Will throwing all the offenders in jail solve anything, I wonder.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *