subscribe: Posts | Comments

Researchers compare non-medical vaginal surgery to genital mutilation

3 comments

Summary of story from The Independent, August 24, 2011

Vaginal reconstruction surgery that is carried out even when medically unnecessary is similar to the female genital mutilation carried out predominantly in Africa, say researchers at the Elizabeth Garret Anderson Hospital in London.

This claim comes after a study published in the British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology found that 40 per cent of women enquiring about the operation still wanted it to go ahead even after being told that their labias were normal sized.

The number of operations being carried out, during which the labia at the entrance to the vagina is made smaller, has risen five-fold in a decade.

Over 2000 NHS operations were performed last year alone. It is estimated that thousands more may have been carried out privately.

It is believed that pornography and an increase in the number of television programmes that focus on cosmetic surgery are the two main reasons why women have the procedure (see WVoN coverage).

The study focused on 33 women, with an average age of 23, all of whom had enquired about the operation.

Despite only three having asymmetry, where surgery would be appropriate, 40 per cent said they would still go through the procedure – for aesthetic reasons.

Sarah Creighton, of the Elizabeth Garret Anderson Hospital, who led the study said: “It has not been tested [legally] and no one has been taken to court. But the question is whether it is being done for non-medical purposes. I think it is.”

“In that case, it is difficult to see how it is anything other than cultural.”

“Surgeons will say the woman was upset, couldn’t wear jeans, or ride a bike, or have sex because she complained of being uncomfortable. But no one has said surgery will change that.”

She also adds that without medical necessity there is nothing to separate the operation from genital mutilation, since both are performed for cultural reasons.

Female genital mutilation is illegal in Britain.

  1. Interesting. Yes and no, I can see why they make the comparison but I imagine none of the women electing for this procedure are held down and cut without benefit of anaesthesia or sterile operating conditions.

    • This was my thought too. I suppose the comparison is because psychological hold can be harmful just as physical brutality can… not that I’m suggesting in any way that women opting for ‘designer vaginas’ are in as much danger as girls who are at risk of genital mutilation.

      • It does seem to be part of the same old ‘women must be this… ‘ narrative while illustrating the privilege wealthy Western women have in being able to choose how and where to do something like this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *