subscribe: Posts | Comments

South Korea tackles subway groping with women-only carriages

5 comments

Summary of story from the Los Angeles Times, August 17, 2011

City officials in Seoul aim to combat sex crimes against women on the subway by reintroducing female-only carriages on evening trains, following the examples of Japan, India, Taiwan and Indonesia.

Seoul’s vast subway network carries 6.4 million passengers daily and is crowded at the best of times. During the rush hour, the clammy, claustrophobic ordeal has been called a “hell ride”.

Travelling late at night also carries increasing risks for women. Every year more and more female passengers are subjected to groping and other sexual crimes while on the subway.

But reactions to the idea of women-only carriages have been mixed. Some have criticized the idea in the context of an overcrowded and congested subway system. One man posting online called it “outrageous”, asking: “How about the elderly and families with young kids?”

Women have also  expressed doubts: one thought deviants would know where to find female subway victims late at night, another wondered if women might be harassed for not sitting in their designated carriages.

Women’s rights activists contend that female-only carriages are not the solution to subway sex crimes. “We believe that separating women and men won’t solve the fundamentals of the problem,” said Lee Seon-mi of the Korea Sexual Violence Relief Center.

“To really tackle the problem, you need to understand the crimes. General education is more important.”

  1. Diana Davies says:

    I can see some advantages to this I suppose but I’m angry that women seem to always bear the responsibility for crimes against them. It’s women who are told not to wear short skirts & not to go out at night alone. Now they have to sit separately?

    Here’s an idea, how about gropers-only carriages?

    • That was my reaction to this article too. 🙂

      How about ‘men only’ carriages with posters in them explaining that they are necessary because women are being harassed and assaulted? I imagine the language would need to be of the ‘your sisters, mothers, daughters, wives’ etc. Same outcome – segregation based on a female/male divide – different emphasis.

  2. Caroline Donaldson says:

    I have mixed feelings about this myself. Whilst in Dubai recently, I greatly appreciated the women-only carriages on the metro, which had army officers at every station to deter men from using them. For one thing it means you don’t have to sit next to a man who feels it essential to his identity to spread his legs out so widely that they intrude into the personal space of any woman who sits next to him! Why do they do this?

    More seriously though, in some ways I suppose this issue reflects the wider debate of whether women are better off inhabiting separate “man-free” spaces (girls’ schools, shared houses, etc) or whether feminism should be mainstreamed into society.

  3. ‘another wondered if women might be harassed for not sitting in their designated carriages.’

    I suspect that this would be the case. It is the consequence of making women responsible for avoiding harassment – women who voluntarily put themselves in places where harassment is possible will be considered to have been ‘asking for it’. Eugh. Why can’t men just not be dicks and keep their hands to themselves. Feminism isn’t meant to just be about creating special safe spaces, it’s about men taking responsibility for making everywhere a safe space. But I know I am preaching to the converted here on lovely WVoN!

    So, I instinctively don’t like this idea, but then, I don’t think I would object if it was introduced in Britain (hypothetically…). I would like to be able to get a bus with my male friends, but that is outweighed by my desire to not spend every journey I take on packed London nightbuses gently lifting anonymous hands from creeping up my thigh and replacing them back somewhere near their owner. Remember that scene in Repulsion where Catherine Deneuve walks along a corridor with dozens of hands melting out of the wall? Well, that.

    • ‘Gently’? Think I’d be far more tempted to haul the hand up in the air and shout out merrily ‘Has someone lost this? Found it on my thigh!’

      I probably wouldn’t. But I’d be tempted to. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *