Screening has no impact on breast cancer mortality
Summary of story from the Guardian, August 2, 2011
A paper published in the current British Medical Journal has found, much to the researchers’ surprise, that screening has no impact on breast cancer mortality.
Having set out to demonstrate that the introduction of mammography screening in some European countries was associated with a fall in breast cancer mortality, compared to those European countries who had delayed offering this service, they found that it made no difference.
Instead they discovered that paired neighbouring countries had experienced the same fall in breast cancer mortality, whether or not screening had been introduced.
Furthermore, the steepest fall in mortality was among women under 50 who had not necessarily been invited for screening in all of the countries.
It concluded that the recent downward trend in breast cancer mortality was nothing to do with screening but due to improvements in treatment and service provision.
Although cancer charities have blamed lifestyle for the increasing incidence of breast cancer, most commentators have so far ignored the fact that the an important lifestyle choice contributing to this could have been an increase of screenings.
This new evidence suggests that the fall in breast cancer can no longer be attributed to mammography screening, therefore the need for a National Health Screening service is to be reevaluated.











