subscribe: Posts | Comments

The new threat to abortion access in the UK

4 comments

Hannah Boast
WvoN co-editor

Ministers in the British government have signalled their support for a proposal that would introduce independent counselling for women seeking an abortion.

This announcement may seem innocuous, but the amendment needs to be vigorously opposed because it would allow faith-based and anti-abortion groups greater influence over women’s decisions (see WVoN story).

The government’s decision must also be viewed against the background of an increasingly confident and influential Christian right in the UK, which has been boosted by recent successes of the anti-abortion lobby in the United States (see WVoN story).

The proposed change in the law comes ahead of a vote on the Health and Social Care Bill when Parliament reconvenes next week, with a decision on whether the amendment has been accepted due to be announced on September 6.

Supporters of the amendment claim that the mandatory requirement to offer independent counselling will give women “breathing space” to consider their options before deciding whether or not to go ahead with an abortion.

“Independence” in this context means that counselling providers must be unconnected to groups that also provide abortion.

This requirement would exclude charity-run abortion services including the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (Bpas) and Marie Stopes from advising women seeking an abortion.

The amendment was proposed by Conservative backbencher Nadine Dorries, with support from Labour MP Frank Field.

The pair are backed by the campaign group Right to Know, although this organisation’s funding source and the size of its support base is unclear (see WVoN story).

Ms Dorries alleges that abortion providers have a financially-motivated “vested interest” in encouraging greater numbers of women to abort their pregnancies and can therefore not be counted on to provide impartial advice.

Ann Furedi, chief executive of Bpas, rubbished Ms Dorries’ claim in the Guardian yesterday, saying that:

‘Nothing could be further from the truth. I can say with hands on heart that the last thing that anyone involved in abortion wants is for a woman to be having treatment that they are not sure about.

Everybody wants people to walk away feeling that the right thing has been done.’

The grounds for her accusation are dubious, based on some ill-phrased sentences taken from Bpas documents and highlighted by Right to Know, according to the Telegraph.

These include a stated aim to “increase our market share for abortion services provision in the UK”, and a claim in their accounts for 2010/2011 that “an increase in procedures of 13 per cent against a background of falling national trends” was a “significant achievement”.

Is this really enough to warrant changing the entire basis of government policy?

The way in which Ms Dorries frames her amendment in the language of compassionate feminism is also perturbing, if not downright misleading.

“The abortion process is so fast – seven to 14 days. Women who do have doubts or niggles are on the other side before they have a chance to think it through”, she told The Guardian.

“The majority may feel it’s fine but there are a growing number thinking it wasn’t what I wanted to do. As it gets faster and faster more women are falling off the edge. This is a women’s rights issue.”

Ms Dorries is keen to call herself pro-choice, but she has spent much of her six years in Parliament trying to introduce further legal restrictions on abortion, according to this Guardian article.

She also frames her latest amendment in terms of the reduction in abortions she claims it will produce: reportedly 60, 000 out of around 200, 000 currently carried out every year.

The amendment has been opposed by pro-choice groups and charities such as the Family Planning Association and Abortion Rights, as well as Labour MPs including shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper, who share the concern that the proposed amendment would limit women’s access to impartial advice, according to the Guardian.

They fear that anti-abortion groups such as CareConfidential and Life would quickly step in to fill the gap left by the removal of Bpas and Marie Stopes as information providers.

A study published earlier this month by the charity Education for Choice indicates that the quality of advice given by religious and anti-abortion counselling groups can be dangerously poor.

Researchers visited centres around the country posing as women seeking an abortion, and found that “counselling” frequently involved scaremongering about potential health risks, using over-emotive language such as talking about “the child”, and quoting inaccurate statements as fact (see WVoN story).

Dorries’s rebranding of right to life sentiment as a ‘Right to Know’ campaign hijacks the language of empowerment to mask a socially conservative agenda, a trick which has long been part of the linguistic toolkit of the American right (see Jezebel).

There has also been a growing diversification of the Christian right into different organisations and networks which interlace with our political system in unexpected ways, both inside and outside Parliament.

Rather than campaigning as one monolithic body using confrontational language, these groups have followed the American example and subtly reshaped the political landscape to their advantage.

Many see David Cameron’s Big Society project as a chance to introduce their agenda into public services provision, according to the Guardian.

The battle for abortion rights was won before many women alive today were born and many women now take the possibility of accessing a safe and legal abortion for granted.

However, the reality is that most current members of the Cabinet made their opinions on abortion clear in a vote in 2008, when senior Tories – including David Cameron – voted for a reduction, although the proposal was ultimately rejected by a Commons majority.

The reintroduction of abortion into the arena of public debate through this amendment, by this Government, should concern us all, as UK journalist Laurie Penny points out in this Independent article.

It is vital that we lobby our MPs to let them know that we will not tolerate any challenge to our right to control our bodies.

Abortion Rights has a template letter that you can use to contact your MP. Please do so – today.

  1. Postscript: not all Tories are Nadine Dorries.

    This article by Niki Molnar of Conservative Women urges readers to ask their MPs to oppose the amendments: http://cwoblog.blogspot.com/2011/08/health-social-care-bill-termination.html

    Thanks to Clara X of Feminism for Tories for showing it to me.

  2. You talk about having the right to control our bodies. As a woman I feel I already have this control by CHOOSING to use contraceptives such as the pill and condoms to prevent pregnancy. I also CHOOSE whether to risk getting pregnant (as contraceptives can fail) by CHOOSING whether to have sex or not (Im deliberately excluding pregnancy from rape here as that is a separate matter). Therefore I already have the power to choose over what I do with my body. Yet IF I fall pregnant as a result of my CHOOSING to have sex I do not have the right to CHOOSE what to do with the baby growing inside me. No-one has the right to kill another living entity – especially one that has the potential to grow into a beautiful human being but is denied this by having it’s potential interrupted by abortion. I’m a feminist who is anti-abortion because my father tried to pressurise my mother into aborting me. I could so easily have simply become some human waste in a surgical dish. I shudder at the number of people who have had their potential to live interrupted in this way.

    • Pregnancy through rape is not a seperate matter. You say you have the right to CHOOSE what happens to your body – please extend that courtesy to other women who may have different points of view or motivations to yours.

  3. Thank you for your comment Emma – you obviously feel very emotional about this and truly hope that you are never in a situation where you have to make the choice where you have to terminate a pregnancy. However, just as your mother had the right to choose not to, so do other women have the right to make a different choice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *