Equal pay settlement for Sheffield dinner ladies
Summary of story from The Daily Mail, September 21, 2011
Dinner ladies, carers and cleaners employed by Sheffield city council in the UK have won their long-running battle for equal pay.
In an unexpected move, Sheffield council has agreed to settle the case for an undisclosed sum in compensation for the 900 women workers.
The workers were claiming that they had been discriminated against for years, and had been excluded from a bonus scheme that was given to employees in equivalent but male dominated roles such as street cleaners and gardeners.
In some individual cases, the cumulative disparity in pay could be as much as £10,000.
The case, which had gone all the way to the Supreme Court, was due to be heard next month. It’s estimated that if the council had proceeded to court and lost, they would have had to pay somewhere in the region of £20 million in compensation.
Diane Wragg, who has been a council care worker for 24 years, said: ‘This is great news. A lot of people will be really happy.”
Thousands more female workers could win payouts as a result of this settlement.
Dave Prentis, general secretary of public sector union, Unison, said that 40,000 similar cases around the country had been awaiting the court hearing, and encouraged other councils to settle.
He said: “It makes sense the council has seen fit to pay women fairly.”
















This case is similar to thousands taking place across the country. Despite knowing they will ultimately have to settle many councils would rather attempt to use any device possible to discourage future similar actions or support for the individuals or groups involved.
This particular situation arose largely as a result of the privatisation of the local care system so, many women who could have benefited from this result lost the opportunity to use this success to recover what was their due.
It is a disgrace that millions of women working in the public sector remain on lower pay than their male counterparts. In Leeds recently the local authority attempted to use this disparity as a means of justifying the application of a cut in the pay of male workers. Needless to say..many of them came out onto the streets to complain that was unfair.
When we demand equal pay we are considered “troublemakers”…when men do same they soon realise we aren’t asking for favours..just fairness….pity they don’t see the consequences of failing to support us until it impacts them personally!