subscribe: Posts | Comments

Old, poor and Hispanic women suffer over-zealous breast cancer surgery in US

0 comments

Summary of story from Reuters, September 19, 2011

The California cancer registry has shown researchers that of 18,000 women who underwent mastectomy for early-stage breast cancer, one third also had their lymph nodes removed.

The procedure – known as axillary lymph node dissection or ALND, was applied to around 6,000 old, poor or Hispanic women who had under arm lymph nodes removed unnecessarily.

These women all had node-negative tumours, meaning the cancer hadn’t spread beyond the breast.

Their treatment contradicts the 2005 American Society of Clinical Oncology guidelines that recommend that surgeons consider removing only the lymph nodes closest to the tumour (called sentinel lymph nodes) to discover if the disease has spread beyond the breast.

This alternative, gentler process also helps avoid side effects like pain, swelling and numbness.

Even if the disease has spread, a study in the Journal of the American Medical Association earlier this year suggested removing the lymph nodes doesn’t help women live longer, as long as they are getting radiation and chemotherapy.

Dr Sharon Lum, a breast surgeon who worked on the new study, said: “The women that were getting this unnecessary surgery were more likely to be of lower socioeconomic status, were older, or were Hispanic.”

In an editorial in the Archives of Surgery, Dr Jan H Wong of East Carolina University in Greensville, North Carolina, said the study raises troubling questions.

“Might this data suggest the selective management of women with early breast cancer based on the level of insurance coverage?”

He added that the study is ‘a wake-up’ call that health care systems need to rigorously examine the process of care and to intervene with corrective action where appropriate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *