subscribe: Posts | Comments

Scrutiny required after legal report on proposed health service bill

0 comments

Sue Tapply
WVoN co-editor

Members of Parliament are about to vote on the biggest proposed changes to England’s National Health Service (NHS) since 1948: 1000 amendments, including, possibly, one on abortion counselling.

Baroness Thornton, the Labour Party’s spokesperson in the House of Lords, has warned that the lack of scrutiny in the House of Commons — the 1,000 amendments mean there will be just 40 seconds of parliamentary time to consider each one — could see the bill be put into a specialist committee to examine whether there is enough time to debate the reforms.

And abortion is not the only issue of concern.

Uncertainty over the actual significance of the bill have led members of the pressure group 38 Degrees to fund independent legal advice on the implications of the UK government’s proposals to change the NHS in England.

Harrison Grant solicitors and the specialist barristers Rebecca Haynes and Stephen Cragg were engaged to give their legal opinions on two aspects of the Health and Social Care Bill: the removal of Secretary of State for Health’s ‘Duty to provide or secure provision of NHS services’ and the impact of competition and procurement law on the NHS.

They found that the bill will remove the duty of the Secretary of State to provide or secure the provision of health services.

This ‘duty’ has been a common and very important feature of all previous NHS legislation since 1946.

And now a “hands-off clause” will severely curtail the Secretary of State’s ability to influence the delivery of NHS care to ensure everyone receives the best healthcare possible.

They also found that the Bill contains a number of measures which will increase competition.

These plans, the report points out, will lead to a system geared heavily in favour of private companies.

They include removing the limit on the amount of income NHS hospitals can earn from private health services and permitting new groups to outsource commissioning work to private companies.

And the legislation does not currently contain measures to stop private companies being contracted to provide commissioning services to consortia and therefore profiting from spending multi-million-pound health budgets

Nor does the legislation contain measures to stop private companies poaching services in a way which undermines the ability of the NHS to deliver essential services like Intensive Care Units, Accident and Emergency, emergency cover, teaching, training and research.

At a meeting of the Liberal Democrat parliamentary party on the night of September 5, deputy prime minister Nick Clegg admitted that ministers still had to work hard to clarify the bill for MPs and peers with concerns.

This means Lib Dem peer Lady Williams could be backed by Liberal Democrat ministers if she attempts to amend the bill to guarantee that the health secretary has a legal duty to deliver a comprehensive health service free at the point of need.

Conservative MP – and former GP – Sarah Wollaston maintains that structural changes to the NHS have passed the point of no return.

But she does concede that the Secretary of State should put in place additional safeguards to limit private income generation by foundation trusts.

Labour MP Yvette Cooper, the shadow women’s minister, yesterday attacked the prime minister for adopting a “cack-handed” approach to the sensitive issue of abortion as MPs prepared to debate a cross-party amendment that would change the counselling system.

And Labour MP Diane Abbot has warned that the issue of abortion counselling (see WVoN coverage) is one of the trickier issues for Cameron to deal with.

For Cameron, she says, it is not just one of those random issues that flares up and then disappears, it has to be looked at in the wider context of social conservatism, and his problem of how to manage his own right wing.

Ms Cooper said: “The government’s handling of this […] will have made many women very worried that ministers were initially so careless about women’s rights to the health advice and care they need.”

WVoN comment: I shall keep it short. “Very worried” has to be an understatement.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *