The complex relationship between religion and family planning in Africa
Summary of story from Think Africa Press, September 14, 2011
Think Africa Press asked four experts about the role of religion in family planning in Africa, and their answers paint a complex picture of the relationship between religion and fertility.
Sara Yeatman, Assistant Professor, Department of Health and Behavioural Sciences, University of Colorado, questions how much impact the Pope has on the day-to-day behaviour of African Catholics.
Although Christianity and Islam are “blossoming” in Africa, she says her research in rural Malawi shows that congregational leaders are “more relevant than denominational edicts for shaping the use of family planning”.
Rural Malawians interact with their local religious leader and fellow parishioners, she says, rather than with denominational leaders.
In the absence of religious texts, especially in the local language, rural Malawians come to understand issues of doctrine through their local religious leader.
In 2005, Yeatman’s research team asked religious leaders in rural Malawi what they thought of modern family planning; 80 per cent approved. Although Catholic leaders were the least likely to approve, 60 per cent of them did.
Catholic women were also found to be the most likely to use contraceptives, mainly due to their higher level of education.
Yeatman says that a woman’s denomination was found to have no relationship to her contraceptive use, although women were more likely to have used family planning if they had a religious leader who approved.
She says one of the main reasons women may not use a certain contraceptive method is the fear of side effects.
Michael Jennings, Senior Lecturer, Department of Development Studies, School of African and Oriental Studies, London, says that although “a strong case for the negative role of religion in this area can be made, moving to the particular generates a more nuanced, complex picture”.
Jennings claims that although many official religious teachings conflict with family planning best practice, many individuals, “including in mission or religious-linked medical institutions”, have encouraged family planning.
Religion outside Africa has had a more negative impact, he says, including the US Christian Right’s influence on policy under George W Bush’s presidency.
Funding for condoms as a preventative measure was limited, and funding was withdrawn from any organization advising on or undertaking abortion services.
Jennings cites the example of a Marie Stopes clinic in Nairobi’s Mathare slums, serving 300,000 people, which was forced to close as a direct result of these policy changes.
George Gathigi, Andrew Mellon Fellow at Hampshire College, Amherst, Massachusetts, says that the relationship between fertility and religion in Africa is not well understood.
He says that religion expresses “norms relevant to fertility” and that “the adoption of contraception is a cultural process that is dependent on access to and the acceptability of information and the contraceptives themselves.”
In West Africa, he says that fertility levels among Muslims have been found to be low where they are the majority group and higher where they are a minority.
John Painter, Professor of Theology, Charles Sturt University, Australia, says that political and religious leaders alike are reluctant to address the problem of the human population explosion.
“Burgeoning human populations are sometimes perceived positively as expanding economic markets,” he says, “and religious and cultural resistance to the use of family planning methods exacerbates this problem”.
He writes that the Genesis creation story “has been taken as a licence to exploit the earth”.











