subscribe: Posts | Comments

UK government U-turn on changes to abortion counselling

0 comments

Summary of story from The Guardian, August 31, 2011

The UK government has made a U-turn and decided to vote against a Conservative backbench amendment seeking to stop certain charities from offering abortion counselling.

It has now reversed its position on moves to strip the charities of their exclusive responsibility for counselling women seeking an abortion.

Instead, it will advise Members of Parliament (MPs) to vote against proposals from Conservative backbencher Nadine Dorries (see WVoN coverage) if they are put before the House of Commons next week.

She claims to want to provide women seeking abortion with counselling that is independent of the actual abortion provider.

Currently abortion advice is provided by charities such as the British Pregnancy Advisory Service and Marie Stopes International.

Dorries says this produces a conflict of interest, as the charities providing counselling are also paid to carry out abortions.

She also claims that her amendment to a law currently going through the House of Commons, requiring counselling from an independent provider, would reduce abortions by a third, and prevent women being rushed into abortions they may later regret .

Pro-choice campaigners say the change would delay abortions and could strip abortion services of their ability to provide counselling.

If the amendment is selected next week for debate, it will be a free vote for MPs, as is the tradition with the most controversial “matters of conscience”.

It is understood that the prime minister, the health ministers and other senior members of the government will vote against, and coalition MPs will be steered to vote against it.

The Labour Party has adopted a similar position.

But a combination of the unpredictable intake of new Conservative MPs – some social conservatives, some modernisers – the number of Roman Catholic Labour MPs, and the high degree of nuance of the amendment make it extremely unclear which way the vote will go.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *