Calls for reform of tax office after ‘sweetheart deal’ with bank
Summary of story from The Guardian, October 26, 2011
Margaret Hodge, as the chairwoman of the UK’s public accounts committee, wants the cabinet secretary to investigate demands from senior Members of Parliament (MPs) for a fundamental reform of the country’s tax office, Revenue and Customs (HMRC).
The call comes after HMRC admitted “mistakenly” giving millions of pounds to some of the richest bankers and corporations in the world.
The MPs want the cabinet secretary, Gus O’Donnell, to look at how to bring greater accountability to the Revenue’s dealings with big business.
The public accounts committee has accused Dave Hartnett, permanent secretary for tax at HMRC, of lying to parliament about an abnormally favourable contractual agreement, known as a ‘sweetheart deal’, he cut with Goldman Sachs.
But even before the Goldman Sachs deal, Hartnett – Britain’s most powerful taxman – attracted controversy.
He agreed to allow Vodafone to escape a minimum of £1 billion in tax.
Freedom of Information requests have revealed that Harnett has enjoyed 107 lunches over two years with corporations, the “big four” accountancy firms, and banks, including Goldman Sachs.
Hartnett admitted to the Public Accounts committee that he had confirmed a deal that allowed the bankers to escape the interest and penalties on unpaid tax that ordinary citizens and businesses must pay if they fall foul of the Revenue.
Hodge says she wants O’Donnell to accept that corporations are not entitled to the same privacy rights as individuals.
The committee also wants “to see a proper separation of powers” inside the Revenue.
At present, Hartnett makes deals and then, acting in his role as tax commissioner, approves his own actions, a situation Hodge described as absurd.











