Incitement to sexual hatred law needed in wake of Yeates murder
Summary of story from the Guardian, October 28, 2011
The murder trial of Joanna Yeates, who was murdered in Bristol (England) last December (see WVoN coverage), has come to an end.
Vincent Tabak, the Dutch engineer who was accused of her murder was found guilty yesterday and sentenced to life imprisonment.
The prosecution had repeatedly contended that Tabak’s actions were sexually motivated. Following the verdict it has emerged that he regularly accessed violent pornography.
Police found disturbing images on his computer of women being degraded by men, tortured, strangled during sex, and bound and gagged, along with a film in which two women were packed into a car boot.
Journalist Julie Bindel argues that it follows that a man who masturbates to porn involving the severe degradation and abuse of women is likely to be attracted to the idea of doing it in reality.
Yeates suffered over 40 injuries to her face, throat and arms, her t-shirt had been pulled up to reveal her breasts and a sample of Tabak’s DNA was detected on her chest.
It has also emerged that before the murder Tabak had sought contact with prostitutes, suggesting that he did not only passively engage with his fantasies.
American psychologist Melissa Farley, recently conducted research in which she compared men who admit to paying for sex with those who do not, and found that:
“Over time, as a result of their prostitution and pornography use, sex buyers reported that their sexual preferences changed such that they sought more sadomasochistic and anal sex.”
Farley’s study also showed that rates of acceptance of rape myths and violence against women were higher in high pornography users than low pornography users, suggesting there is, whatever the porn apologists say, a direct link between violence against women and pornography.
Pornography causes harm, and not only in the most straightforward of ways. For violent pornography to exist, women have to come to harm in its production. There also has to be a market for it, meaning men get a sexual thrill from seeing women hurt and abused.
Outlawing violent pornography will not prevent sexual violence and pornography occurring, nor does it create men like Tabak.
The danger is in normalising sadistically violent imagery; the merging of pain, torture, degradation and sexual pleasure reinforces the view held by some that women are inferior to men and can be abused.
Perhaps it is time to consider legislation akin to that which criminalises racial hatred.
Introducing a crime of incitement to sexual hatred would allow us to sanction those who produce and consume images of females being tortured and violated because of their gender.
Tabak is an acute example of how pornography can feed sadistic fantasy to the point where it is no longer enough to be a passive viewer.
















What I find so incredible is the judge’s insistence that Tabak’s obsession with viewing women being strangled had nothing to do with his behaviour towards Jo Yeates and that therefore his choice of porn material was irrelevant. Surely it is evidence of motive, which last time I looked was one of the three components of a case, motive, opportunity and gain. I can’t think of a single case of terrorism where the evidence that a defendant had scanned the internet for bomb making recipes would have been deemed unlinked to their later planting and detonation of a bomb, or am I going stark raving bonkers here? The men in charge of this society seem to have collectively lost the entire bleeding plot …