More expert testimony could have aided jury in murder case
Summary of story from WeNews, October 20, 2011
At her trial in New York, Barbara Sheehan admitted killing her husband, a retired police sergeant, in 2008.
However, a jury of nine women and three men failed to convict Sheehan after hearing about the two decades of sadistic and systematic abuse she suffered at the hands of her husband.
Sheehan had suffered constant death threats both to her and her family until, in February 2008, he pointed a gun at her head. She testified: “I knew he was going to kill me right then.”
While the prosecution portrayed Sheehan as a cold-blooded killer, the argument raged as to whether expert testimony on “battered woman syndrome” or “battered woman defence” should be allowed.
The testimony would have educated the jury as to why a woman would resort to murder – that she had to “kill or be killed”. The trial’s original judge ruled it out and an appeal by the defence was denied.
It was only when judge Barry Kron took over the case that expert testimony was allowed, albeit with limitations imposed.
Jacquelyn Campbell, professor and researcher at Johns Hopkins University, wasn’t allowed to assess Sheehan. Nor was she allowed to discuss the factors that would show that the situation was likely to end in homicide. She was only allowed to give the most general testimony.
The evidence she was unable to give could have been even more important. Of the 20 or so indicators that there was likely to be a lethal end, nearly all were present in the Sheehan case. Furthermore, having a partner in the police force is a vital factor in the inability to report abuse.
Evidently the jury struggled to come to the verdict they did: not guilty of murder, but guilty of the illegal possession of a firearm. In this case a more in-depth use of expert testimony could have made it a lot easier for them to come to a lenient decision.
















shame that the article doesnt show the reasoning behind the jury’s aquittal or why there were limitations on the expert.
The linked article does go into a bit more detail but we’re not likely to get the reasoning of any jury unless we’re on it, realistically.
I suppose they have to reconcile the idea that this woman was a helpless and thoroughly cowed victim with the idea that she could think enough to know what was coming and shoot first. There really isn’t a lot of knowledge about this, still – the first question asked is usually ‘but why didn’t she leave?’
I’d also like to know why the expert testimony wasn’t allowed. I suspect it was to do with a legal gambit and lawyers vying for position but that’s only a suspicion.
and how on earth can a judge (the first one) simply dismiss an expert witness completely? “No we don’t need to understand the effects of 20 years of abuse”? I’d like to hear that reasoning, but my fear is that there was no reasoning involved.
On the positive side, despite not having the full story the jury still aquitted. Dare we say public awareness is increasing?