Most UK migrant sex workers aren’t forced or trafficked, study says
Lindsay Carroll
WVoN co-editor
The majority of migrant sex workers in the UK aren’t trafficked or forced into their work, according to a new study published by an expert on migration.
The research was carried out by Dr Nick Mai, of the Institute for the Study of European Transformations at London Metropolitan University, who explores topics of migration, gender, sexuality and media.
His work suggests that most migrant sex workers in the UK choose their work, driven by a lack of other options.
The study, entitled ‘Migrants in the UK Sex Industry,’ carried out interviews with 100 sex workers – 67 women, 24 men and nine transgender – representing all sectors of the sex industry and its main origins (South America, Eastern Europe, the European Union and South East Asia).
Based on the interviews, Dr Mai found that migrants often choose sex work to avoid unrewarding and at times exploitative conditions of non-sexual jobs, so as to maintain a ‘dignified’ standard of living and improve that of their families in their country of origin.
About thirteen percent of the female interviewees felt they had been somewhat misled, trafficked or forced into sex work. Six percent felt they had been forced into the industry.
While those figures represent only a minority, the study shows that the stigmatisation of sex work and the lack of legal immigration status makes sex workers vulnerable to violence and crime.
The study also suggests that the criminalisation of sex work will only force the industry further underground, making it even more difficult for workers to assert their rights.
Catherine Stephens, a member of Dr Mai’s advisory board and a member of the International Union of Sex Workers, said in a news release that the UK can only successfully target sex trafficking by making policy based on evidence.
“There is currently a climate of fear amongst London sex workers due to police activity that is driven by hype and misinformation promoted by NGOs with a financial vested interest in the anti-trafficking industry, who are ideologically opposed to commercial sex,” Stephens said.
Dr Mai’s study, funded by the Economic & Social Research Council, is the largest qualitative research on the experiences of migrant sex workers in London.

















I would question whether sex work as an alternative to exploitative badly paid other work represents a real ‘choice’.
Also, was there a representative from an organisation that works with victims of sex work and sex trafficking on the advisory panel of the research team, to counterbalance the view of the International Union of Sexworkers?
I doubt that NGOs are driven by financial vested interest in the anti trafficking ‘industry’ (whatever that is) but I do believe they are motivated by the evidence of the work they do with trafficked women and children into the sex industry who are then subjected to systematic rape, violence, and physical and psychological torture.
They have included interviewees from sex worker support projects and because of that they claim that “the actual number of interviewees who feel that they have been exploited is higher than the one which has occurred randomly(9%) and which would be closer to a statistical representation”. This is not necessarily true when you look at how they have done the selection. The section about how they chose their sample is somewhat vague in my opinion.
Also if this is a representative cross section then that means that of sex workers, 24% are men and 9% transgender. Now I don’t know the actual numbers but those seem off to me.
What is a real choice in a capitalist and patriarchal system?
Good question but ask the same to all workers, not just sex workers.
The anti-trafficking industry receives a lot of money and have a real financial interest in inflating the figures.
I would suggest that anyone who works in an industry where rape and psychological torture are present is in a very inhumane industry. The fact that the anti slavery industry receives a ‘lot of money’ doesn’t necessarily mean that they inflate their figures, just that they have the most access to the victims of sex slavery. The fact that 19% of the women had been ‘somewhat misled’ or forced into sex work is an inditement of the industry’s appalling lack of credibility in taking care of its workers. I don’t think we can really compare sex slaves with other workers as to my knowledge, there are few other industries where rape, physical and psychological attack are such common occurences in the working environment.
Amazing to finally see this in print! ‘Based on the interviews, Dr Mai found that migrants often choose sex work to avoid unrewarding and at times exploitative conditions of non-sexual jobs,’ this comment reflects what migrant sex workers keep saying but for some reason people refuse to hear it.
What is it about this issue that is so hard to understand – or maybe it’s just that it lets down the abolitionist arguments against sex work.
Surely a massive issue here is that non-sexual jobs are so unrewarding and exploitative that people would prefer to sell their bodies than do them that needs addressing?
This might be an explanation as to why people turn to sex work but it should not be used as a justification for it.
We should be ashamed at that state of affairs.
I disagree Jen. I have worked as a sex worker for 24 years and my body is completely in tact. Sex workers do not ‘sell our bodies’, we do however sell a service that includes physical labour, like many other forms of work. It may be hard for people who have not worked as sex workers to recognise that our work is rewarding. For us as sex workers it comes as no surprise to see this. I find my work very enjoyable. Like all service industry work there are days I tire of dealing with the public but for the most part I enjoy my clients, enjoy my income and enjoy the company of my colleagues – other sex workers. I do however, highly dislike the stigma resulting from stereotypes about sex work and sex workers and bore very quickly with people that have no ability to critically analyse mainstream understandings of issues. I have worked alongside many migrant sex workers who are sick of the racism underpinning the sensationalist portrayal of their experiences.
Having browsed the ‘final policy-relevant report’ I’m struck by the lack of gender perspective.